In June 2010, we spent 11 nights in a 2 BR Lake View. We were originally assigned to room 7605 which is inside the "C" and overlooks the pool and the other half of BLT. You had to stand to the right side of the window and look left, to see the lake. We paid over $15,000 for the vacation package, (through Small World Travel) and it was supposed to include a "Lake View". Frankly, many of the standard views I've seen posted here are better than our supposed "Lake View".
I called the front desk and after much back and forth, with them (desk personnel and her manager) telling me 7605 is a "Lake View" and me assuring them that 75% of my view is of the building opposite mine, they agreed to move me. Actually, I requested they refund me the difference between a lake and standard view as I was not willing to pay the "Lake View" premium for such a poor lake view. At that, the manager moved me to room 7602. It was still a lousy lake view, as there were swamp trees blocking almost half of our lake view, but we did have a decent view of the MK.
I have a June 2011 trip planned at BLT and again requested a "Lake View". I'm a little nervous about getting a bad lake view again, but I'm not that worried as this time we're
DVC members staying on points. If it's bad, it'll be okay since we'll be returning soon after.
BTW, we had our SWT agent request a high floor, even numbered, north facing room. We obviously got none of those. I checked in online 10 days prior to our stay. We checked in at 10am on a Sunday. At that time, room 7605 was ready. When I complained about room 7605, they told me the "only other lake view room that will be available today won't be ready until after 4pm". So, at 10am on a Sunday, I was led to believe there were only 2 LVs available, 7605 and 7602.