Bice or Emeril's?

[Princess Mommy]

I have reservations at Emeril's for my DH's birthday in September, but I am wondering~
We are staying in the PBH- should I switch to Bice instead?
Has anyone eaten at either or the two? Or both?

 

[RyGuy]

I have heard some bad things about Bice from several different people. Emeril's is always a good choice.

 

[Motherfletcher]

Another vote for Emeril's or Tchoup Chop.

 

[antmaril]

I have not eaten at Bice, so I can't comment. I have, however, eaten at Emeril's and Tchoup Chop (3x). The food at Emeril's and TC is fantastic, however, I prefer Tchoup Chop. I think the atmosphere is better and we just LOVE it. We went to Emeril's for my 50th birthday and they put us upstairs in a smallish room. It was kind of boring and it didn't real feel like we were
anyplace special. If I go to Emeril's again, I want to be on the main level. The food was delicious, especially the banana cream pie!!! (The banana cream pie is also offered to Tchoup Chop.)

Hope this is helpful. Have fun!

 

[webray]

Definately Emeril's or give Tchoup Chop a try. We like Tchoup Chop even better than Emeril's.

Bice, however is another story. The food is down right terrible. The service is horrible. We were just there three weeks ago. We ended up with a free night, and although we had already ruled Bice out because of the horrible reviews..we didn't feel like going anywhere else and gave Bice a try anywhere. Boy were we sorry. Bice doesn't even come close to being in the Del Fino category. Definately stay away from Bice.

 

[ElizabethB]

Really sorry to hear about the bad meal you had at Bice, Webray. Delfino Riviera was one of our favorite places to dine. We miss it. We'll definitely skip Bice, given your experience.

 

[kellymonaghan]

I've eaten at both and would vote for Emeril's, unless DH is an Italian food freak.

 

[webray]

I've eaten at both and would vote for Emeril's, unless DH is an Italian food freak.

Even if your DH likes italian food, Bice is not the place to go. Head to Mama Della's for a great Italian meal.

 

[kellymonaghan]

Yeah, what webray said.

 

[Princess Mommy]

I am SO RELIEVED I asked!
I was going to cancel Emeril's b/c Bice was right inside our resort, but I decide to ask here first!
I am keeping what I have! Thanks everyone!

 

[webray]

Great Decision!