I just want to chime in that I love everyone’s respectful response to people being upset about the pools in this group! In the Facebook group, lots of people chiming in that people should just be thankful to be in Hawaii—if the pool is too cold for people to enjoy, people can be thankful somewhere less expensive haha.
We went in December, and while I found the pools to be an ok temperature for me (I wore a thermal rash guard over my suit), my five year old thought they were cold and wanted to be in the hot tub instead even though he was a wearing a wetsuit. At the time we went, all areas of the pool were still advertised on the website as being heated year round to between 82 and 86 degrees, and only the Ka Maka grotto pool was that warm. On Facebook the pool drama started being mentioned in November, and someone brought a pool thermometer and posted all the temps while we were there.
We still plan on going again this year because everything else was wonderful, but the calm bay and pools are one of the main reasons I’m opting for Aulani with my small kids. Prior to kids, I had never even stepped foot into a pool while in Hawaii!