In the interest of saving money, I think Mears would be your best bet. We have arrived in Orlando at 1am on 2 different occasions, once we took Mears and once we took Tiffany Town Car. During the late night hours Mears only operates their lower level desk (the floor below baggage claim). We waited perhaps 20 minutes for a van, and the van stopped at 2 other Disney resorts before dropping us off at All Star Movies. We arrived at our resort around 2:15am. Tiffany was of course the faster method of transportation but also almost twice as expensive (for just 2 people). We arrived at our resort around 1:45am.