We are just back, and hands down, the favorite meal we ate inside the park was the family feast at Three Broomsticks. It was an awesome value at $49.99 for 4 portions (4 rotisserie chicken quarters, 4 sets of 2-3 ribs, 4 ears of roasted corn on the cob, with family style portions of roasted potatoes, roasted veggies (broccoli, carrots, red peppers), and salad.
Finegan's was a very close second, with a wide variety of food and a great location.
We also ate at Richter's (burgers and chicken sandwiches, "cafeteria food" per dh), Simpsons Fast Food Blvd (we had fish, pizza, chicken, big pink - very average), and the Hard Rock just outside the parks (good food and service, typical of a HRC anywhere).
Warning: the days we lunched at Simpsons and at Three Broomsticks (6/7 and 6/12) the credit card systems went down. Completely kaput. They were forced to use the old fashioned imprint machines in order to take credit cards, and in this day and age when you just need the numbers to go nuts online, that is simply not secure enough for me. Fortunately, we had cash "just in case". Unfortunately, this can kill your AmEx discount. At Simpsons, they took my
AAA card for the discount even without the voucher, but if I didn't have the card, they would not have given me a discount, even though I had 2 different AmEx accounts with me. At Three Broomsticks, they fudged me an AP discount, since it was "their issue." In both cases, I had to ask (nicely!) for them to honor the fact that I could have paid with a card that gave me a discount in order to get it.
We did use the AmEx for all other meals and snacks (except the carts), and they gave us the AmEx discount with no problems. I specifically asked as I handed the card over each time.