Another vote for POFQ! We LOVE this resort because of its size. Plus, we honeymooned here and thought it was very romantic! We had a king bed, waterview room (right on the corner by the "river"). A short walk to everywhere--pool, food court, store, bus stop, boat launch. We were spoiled! Since there is only one bus stop you are always first on/first off. Granted, you have to wait through 3 more stops at POR but since you are first on you pretty much always have a seat (going--coming back you may not).
We have stayed also at CSR and there are many, many people who love it but we are not them. We did not care for this resort. It is beautiful (especially in the evening) but room and service was not impressive. We did not care for the food court at all and its way too spread out for us. After staying at POFQ, at this resort you just feel like you walk forever. Stayed 3 nights but never got to the pool (rain) so I can't tell you about that. It looked nice from our walks though (kind of far away). We stayed in the Casitas which is closest to the main buildings. According to DH, "we will not stay there again."
But each to his own...choose the theme you like and try it out. If you don't like it, choose a different resort next time. That is the wonderful thing about WDW!! So much to choose from!!
loveswdw