Best Deal on current incentives

You don’t feel that Yacht Club, Beach Club, Boardwalk, and Swan/Dolphin are its own unique bubble?
Sure it is. Not the same scale and history to be comparable to MK area though. Hence, to me, there’s two major bubbles: all the awesomeness that’s roughly east to west along BVD, and MK/Bay Lake.

The drive from Riv to DAK, for example, really isn’t bad at all, which got me on to this train of thought.
 

We have stayed at both.

My girls lean towards the Poly for two reasons:
- The monorail.
- To us, the Poly feels like it has two different Disney bubbles. The old school feel of the original resort and the new tower is “fancier.”
We got the Poly first because we love it so much for similar reasons as you stated. Then we got the Riv (after two sleep around point resale purchases). So...start with the poly and add on at the Riv!
 
Or do RIV direct and Poly resale 😉
My confession not in the confessions thread - I'm 50/50 on points but I'm starting to be over resale. I did direct/resale/resale/direct, and I just...I don't want restrictions on resorts. I don't want 4 months from offer to points. I just wanna get my points and use them where I want...team direct from this point on!
 
My confession not in the confessions thread - I'm 50/50 on points but I'm starting to be over resale. I did direct/resale/resale/direct, and I just...I don't want restrictions on resorts. I don't want 4 months from offer to points. I just wanna get my points and use them where I want...team direct from this point on!
For me, some of this is due to the lack of truly good deals on resale right now. Three years ago I got SSR for $68. Two years ago I got OKW-E for $70. And last year I got AUL for $78. I, too, am looking at some direct points right now. But if deals like the above were still around, I'd be buying resale.
 
The thing with RIV is that, since the restrictions, you need to know that you're going to love it for life.
To be honest, you don't, really.

The RIV haters will never be convinced it's not an inferior product, and that's fine.

A lot of people look at DVC as something where they want to maximize resale value if they ever get in a bind or get tired of it (or as an "investment" with appreciating returns, eek).

But, that's just one way to look at it. IMO you don't need to hold a contract anywhere near to end of life to get the value you paid out of it, if you would have spent the cash on similar vacations anyway.
 
I would choose the Poly for a few reasons:

1) Cheaper annual dues, and likely to stay that way.
2) Better resale value if you ever need to sell
3)Overall vibe and location cannot be matched.
I would just amend that to say, if you agree with #3, #1 and #2 are excellent selling points for Poly. If you don’t agree with #3, I would not go with Poly simply because #1 and #2 are true.

I really wanted to agree with #3 because I knew #1 and #2 were true. But, at the end of the day, I just couldn’t.
 
Are RIV dues slightly higher because of the shared Skyliner upkeep? Does Poly not contribute to monorail?
I don’t know the monorail question, but before the addition of the island tower, if you look at the trend of Poly dues vs. RIV dues, Poly was likely on track to exceed RIV dues based on average annual increases. The addition of the island tower brought dues down quite a bit. Who knows what the future holds. As I said in my prior post, the fact they are currently lower is a selling point if you love Poly, but if you don’t, I wouldn’t let it drive your decision making.
 
To be honest, you don't, really.

The RIV haters will never be convinced it's not an inferior product, and that's fine.

A lot of people look at DVC as something where they want to maximize resale value if they ever get in a bind or get tired of it (or as an "investment" with appreciating returns, eek).

But, that's just one way to look at it. IMO you don't need to hold a contract anywhere near to end of life to get the value you paid out of it, if you would have spent the cash on similar vacations anyway.
The choice here--for the poster--was between RIV and Poly. My comment wasn't about how lovely RIV is. (There are many plusses--best cafe, best quick service, one of the three best signature restaurants on property, skyliner, etc.). It was only about the drop in resale value. Compared to Poly, if you had to--or wanted to flip this--it's a pretty steep loss. There have been a couple non-stripped RIV contracts in recent months with asking prices under $100, where as Poly tends to hold value a lot better. It's all due to restrictions, IMO, not desirability of the resort.
 
Are RIV dues slightly higher because of the shared Skyliner upkeep? Does Poly not contribute to monorail?
I would say the biggest difference is the size of the property and upkeep. Riviera grounds are pretty massive, and there is no shared "cash" side of the resort to help spread the cost out.

Poly has DVC but also dedicated cash only rooms.
 
I would say the biggest difference is the size of the property and upkeep. Riviera grounds are pretty massive,
Are they really? Poly seems so spread out with multiple buildings with lots of trees and tropicals everywhere, and RIV with what I thought was a smaller footprint and relatively little landscaping. 🤷‍♀️ But maybe it's down to the cash side differentiating.
 















DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top