I just booked my first DVC stay, switching SSR to BCV at 7 months, 1 bedroom. Super excited for my first Disney trip with my kids and as an adult (My non-Disney loving husband is just along for the ride, would love to be able to change his opinion). I had been planning on and stalking a BWV 1 bedroom pool/garden view room for months. I never imagined that Beach Club would be available but since it was and I've heard how great the pool is and how hard it can be to get into, I booked it. And now I'm second guessing myself. Should I book Boardwalk instead?
Reasons I went Beach Club: not having to walk outside for food and drinks, super close to Epcot, the pool (but maybe this shouldn't be a deciding factor in late January
), complaints of the super long hallways at Boardwalk, BCV has fewer rooms and more popular so there is a better chance that I'll be able to try Boardwalk in the future.
Reasons I'm nervous/rethinking it: I'm from Martha's Vineyard so it seems kind of lame to be spending 8 nights at a Cape Cod themed resort. I've seen mixed reviews about Stormalong Bay with little kids either being great or being scary and overwhelming. Mine will be 4 and 7; neither can swim independently and I doubt that will change by then. My 7-year-old is autistic.
We are planning one day at each park, two at Magic Kingdom and probably two at Epcot. Now that we're definitely walking distance from Epcot, and also thinking about getting the Park Hopper tickets. Planning to rest in the room every afternoon. Planning on a lot of character dining so we're going to go with the Disney dining plan since both my kids will be free in 2026. My spreadsheet shows we will break even or come out a little bit ahead without factoring in drinks/alcohol.
Keep Beach Club or switch to Boardwalk??? And if we stay, any recommendations?
Reasons I went Beach Club: not having to walk outside for food and drinks, super close to Epcot, the pool (but maybe this shouldn't be a deciding factor in late January

Reasons I'm nervous/rethinking it: I'm from Martha's Vineyard so it seems kind of lame to be spending 8 nights at a Cape Cod themed resort. I've seen mixed reviews about Stormalong Bay with little kids either being great or being scary and overwhelming. Mine will be 4 and 7; neither can swim independently and I doubt that will change by then. My 7-year-old is autistic.
We are planning one day at each park, two at Magic Kingdom and probably two at Epcot. Now that we're definitely walking distance from Epcot, and also thinking about getting the Park Hopper tickets. Planning to rest in the room every afternoon. Planning on a lot of character dining so we're going to go with the Disney dining plan since both my kids will be free in 2026. My spreadsheet shows we will break even or come out a little bit ahead without factoring in drinks/alcohol.
Keep Beach Club or switch to Boardwalk??? And if we stay, any recommendations?