My husband, son, son-in-law, and grandkids have fished Bay Lake...can't remember the guides name. They had a very nice time and caught about 40 fish with the largest being around 5 lbs. They would go again in a heartbeat.
They also have gone to Lake Toho on chartered fishing trips. It is about an hour from WDW. They used Capt. Jack's Charters. One day they caught 70 fish with the largest being around 8 lbs. They absolutely had a great time fishing.
Can you tell that I have married and spawned fishing addicts! Sandie
PS - these trips were in May.