We ate at Baskerville's in May for the MurderWatch dinner theatre.
I'm going by memory --
I ordered the tickets over the phone around 30 days before we arrived. Because of this we received a discount ($5?). I am thinking we paid $30 per person (2 adults)
800-624-4109
It was okay.
We arrived about 10 minutes before they were letting guests in. They asked guests to wait in the small bar/pub connected right beside the podium/entrance. VERY VERY SMOKE FILLED!

Your'e fine if you don't breathe or you are use to it. We opted for the hallway.
We were guided to a table. We went for the buffet right away. Even though Baskerville's had just opened, the food was warm at best. It didn't taste bad though. Wasn't outstanding, but was better than I expected -- after all we were there for the show (and to meet Dis-friends). The food would have been pretty good had it been hot.
The show was more like that -- a show. I have been to mystery dinner theatres in other towns, and I was expecting something more along the lines of a storyline, clues, etc.
This was more like a slightly interactive musical. This worked out well for our group, as that way we were able to visit and not really miss a lot. It wasn't the type of interactive entertainment where they do everything but drag you on the floor. I was glad for that.

The MurderWatch dinner one of those things I had been wanting to do. The price I thought was good for a buffet dinner and entertainment. But I probably wouldn't care about doing it again.
The table service was very friendly and the waitresses effificent.