As an AP holder for both WDW and Universal, I go to WDW 4-6 times a year. Up until about a year and half ago, I was one who swore I would never stay offsite and could not understand why anyone would. About a month before our Oct 2012 trip, a coworker who knows I go to WDW alot called me at work one night to ask if I was planning a WDW anytime soon. I told her as a matter of fact we were going in about a month. She said she had several time shares, had banked all the points she could, and was going to lose them if she didn't use them. She offered me a week in Las Vegas for a ridiculously low price or a week at Westgate Towne Center (just one mile outside the Disney gates) for just $400.00. It was too good a price to pass up, so we canceled our CBR reservation and stayed offsite for the first time. We didn't really think we'd like it, but we not only loved it, we were hooked. We came straight home, canceled our May WDW trip and started looking for other offsite options. That's when we discovered Wyndham Bonnet Creek. We've stayed offsite at Bonnet Creek our last three trips and love it there. In fact, this past Sept was a solo trip and I thought I'd make it a budget trip just to save money. I got a quote for a value resort, using my annual pass discount. However, out of curiosity, I also got quotes for a one bedroom at Bonnet Creek. I was shocked that I could stay in a one bedroom at Bonnet Creek cheaper than I could stay at Pop Century, using my annual pass discount. I didn't need that much space, but why should I pay more to stay at a value resort, when I can pay less and stay in a one bedroom condo at a deluxe resort and have a fully equipped kitchen, washer/dryer, jacuzzi, walk in shower, king size bed, two TVs, balcony, two lazy rivers, multiple pools, pool slides, hot tubs, etc. I don't care for the Disney transportation, so would have rented a car anyway. With my annual pass, parking at the parks is free, so parking fees didn't figure into my thoughts. Of course, I went with Bonnet Creek. I love that Bonnet Creek is just a few minutes to Epcot and DS (closer than alot of the Disney owned resorts). You're at DS in like five minutes from when you leave the parking lot. I can't see us ever staying onsite again.
We are going to be back down there in about three weeks and really wanted to stay at Bonnet Creek (would be the fourth time in the last ten months), but couldn't get a ressie for our dates, so went with Blue Heron Resort instead. It's just offsite (like nine blocks from the DTD gates) and looks great, but I know we are going to miss Bonnet Creek. We have annual passes, so could get a discount on a room at WDW, but have no desire to ever stay onsite again in one of those tiny rooms. We love being able to spread out.