Bad Experience at the Art Awards Tonight

Melora

Disney Dreaming
Joined
Jun 26, 2003
Messages
2,556
OK..so we all know that being a mom means we think that our kids are the best. But I am always realistic when it comes to my kids and I never push them or try to make them the best.. only that they do their best.

Some of you might have seen my daughters art work that she did a few weeks back that I posted. Well one of them was getting honored tonight on the local level by the PTA reflections program. We went to the viewing tonight at one of the local schools and I stood around Sarahs work listening to people talk about it as they walked by. Every person who walked by was amazed and had nothing but the best things to say. They all called their friends/relatives over to look. I was so proud..almost bursting.

When we went in for the awards ceremony we sat for 45 minutes listening to the announcer talk about each childs work. She called their name, the name of the art work and what each child had to say about it. When they (finally) got to the last category which was Visual Arts High School Level, the lady called 4 peoples names and gave the spiel about each one (there were 8 kids being honored) then asked for applause and acted as if that was the end. Then she realized she had missed some kids (including Sarah) and hurridly called their names all at once, never telling the name of the art work or anything about it and hurried them off the stage as soon as they all got up there. Sarah ended up with an "Award of Merit" when the other kids got "Awards of Accomandation". Sarah is the type of girl who NEVER thinks she is better than anyone else, always wants other people to get in front of her and is very complimentary of everyone else. When she got back to her seat I could tell that she was upset. Upset that the announcer didnt say anything about her art and also upset (though she didnt really admit it) that she didn't get a higher award. As we were leaving 4 people came up to us and commented that they thought the speaker was rude and could not believe that Sarah didnt get a higher award.

Now I am not saying that I think she was better than all the other kids... but listening to the comments clearly she deserved more than just "runner up". Especially when compared to the ones that got the higher awards. Very few people commented on any of those pieces. Frankly a lot of the high school entries could easily have been done by grade school kids. But mostly I upset that the lady simply dismissed the final 4 kids without saying anything about their work. It was SUCH a huge disappoinment to sit there for 45 minutes and then have that happen...

Thank you for letting me vent.

(Again..... I know all moms think their kids are the best.... But Sarah was so hurt and she NEVER gets hurt when others do better than her...)

This is the piece (partially cut off because it did not all fit on the scanner)


1067798861762_sarah2.jpg
 
I can definately feel your pain.

This is a wonderful learning oppurtunity in teaching Sarah about disappointment and dealing with an unfair world.

Praise her, hug her and teach her to give self praise and recognition.
 
What a gorgeous picture. Wow. This bad experience can be a lesson for your daughter on dealing with disappointment. It's too bad it happened but the main thing is your daughter knows she is a good artist.
 
Oh my! That's a 'blue ribbon' picture in my book. That announcer was just plain stupid and rude IMHO. They should've at least given the same info for the latter bunch that they did for the earlier kids. It sounds like they picked an incompetent person this year. Hopefully your daughter will get beyond this and not let it bother for too long. She deserved a lot better recognition than that!
GREAT JOB SARAH!:sunny:
Kim
 

Wow! As someone who can't put together a straight line, that picture really impresses me. I have a daughter who is also an "artist" and my great uncle had his own studio. I guess this gift skipped three generations in my family. :p

You might tell your daughter that many of the world's greatest artists were never recognized in their time. I doubt if that will be your daughter's fate though, if she continues to paint such magnificent pictures.

Well done Sarah!

Roberta
 
I'm not a big fan of the Reflection's program for many reasons - mainly the fact that it's run by parents. I volunteered for the program once and was very turned off by the attitudes in our district - it was run by the kind of PTA mom's who wore suits to the meeting (and no, they weren't coming from work - they were SAHM's). Don't get me wrong, I'm all for volunteer run programs - but this program in my district attracted the high powered snobby kinds.

That is a beautiful piece of work and it surprises me that she wasn't sent on to state level. It makes me wonder if there was something about her paperwork that wasn't right or they didn't like the way her work met the "theme". Reflection's has very particular rules. I'm kind of surprised the person who was in charge of the Reflections committee at your school hasn't talked to you.
 
That picture is absolutely BEAUTIFUL!!!!! I would frame that and hang that in my house!!! Your daughter truly has a gift in her abilities, there's no doubt about that. By the way, I don't hand out compliments easily but I am blown away by the picture in your post that your daughter did!!!!!

I think you and your daughter have every right to be upset and disappointed in how her award was handled, and the fact that she got a lesser award. It was extremely rude and inconsiderate of that woman to do that to the last 4 students. Please tell your daughtet that her art work speaks for itself. I wish I had an award to give to her myself!!!!
 
Wow!! I absolutely adore that picture. When your post first came on I looked at that first and I was thinking I have to ask her where she got that picture then I started reading. I would love to have that in my house!!

Tell your daughter that she is fabulous!!! If I only had a thumb nail of that talent!!!!
 
I am so sorry that your daughter had to go through that...what a nasty lasdy! :(

How old is your DD? That picture is wonderful!!!!! She should be very proud of herself. I am another one who can't even draw a straight line (even with a ruler) so I am in such awe of people with artistic talent.

Jill
 
What a huge dissappoint for her on a special night.

This piece is just fabulous, wow, I LOVE this painting.

Although her work wasn't recognized in the way it ought to have been that night, it's just a small matter of time before it is and by the people who really understand and appreciate her talent.

Sorry you've both been let down ((HUGS)).
 
what a lovely piece of artwork your DD has created! She has every reason in the world to be disappointed...

I just hope someone had mentioned how rude it was that the other 4 were not represented in the presentation...do you think that the presented didn't have the information?...

Your DD was a wonderful talent. Thank you for sharing her lovely work with us! I surely hope this will not discourage her in anyway to continue entering in contest, her work needs to be seen!


Take care
Lisa
 
An awesome piece of art. You have got to be incredibly proud of that young lady! Don't you hate it when parents, if I read correctly, screw up everything! I've seen it in the local sports progams over and over.

I have to say again that I would love to have that piece of art. I hope that she continues to work on this obvious gift of hers!

Michelle
 
What are the dimensions of the picture and is it for sale? I could care less what the judges thought. That is a fine piece of art.

Adam aka Big Dude
 
I just emailed my DH your DD art work and he would like a copy for Christmas!...so if you are interested in selling! seriously!

Just pm or email me!

Lisa
 
I just have to echo what others in this thread have said... that picture is beautiful! I would hang it my house in a heartbeat.
Your daughter has an amazing talent. :)

It's a shame that the speaker didn't have her act together. :(

Hugs to you both!
 
Thank you all for your kind words....

I did tell Sarah (who is 16) that these programs were run by basically her friends parents who sit around a coffee table deciding who gets what. There was nothing "professional" about the judging.

Her art work (which is an oil pastel..the first one she ever did and it took her about 4 months) measures I would guess 11 x 16. (Rough estimate). I am very glad that we had it professionally matted and protected before we sent it off. When it gets home again we will have it framed and hang it up.

I think I would not have been nearly as upset if they lady had said something about the art. The theme this year was "I was happy when" The picture shows Sarah and her brother with the neighbor (in the middle) walking up our old driveway to go and play. She did it from a photograph that I took of them 10 years ago. She wrote a nice thing on the back talking about how happy those times were.

Its certainly a lesson learned about expectations. I guess I was so dang proud of how impressed everyone was that I didn't give the possiblity of her NOT winning as an option.

Being an artist is her dream that she will never let go of.
 
I was wondering if that picture was from her imagination or from a childhood photo/memory. I really love it.

I wouldn't sell or give away that piece for anything in the world, display it and enjoy it. I'm sure you will :D

Still in awe of her...
 
First of all - she is a very talented artist & she should remember that. Second, the Reflections program is run by non-artists (parent volunteers) and it can be very POLITICAL!!! They are not the proper judges of art. Hopefully, there will be other opportunities for your daughter to shine and get some recognition. And yes, she learned something also about the rudeness of some adults!
 
OMG, that picture is AWESOME:earseek: Forget about the awards and start working on a gallery showing. Stunning work.
 
Wow what a beautiful picture. She has an amazing talent. :hug: for her, people can be so thoughtless sometimes.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom