We had family only. DD was baptized in my hometown and DS was baptized in DH's hometown. Both sets of grandparents, godparents, and a couple of DH's sisters were at the baptisms. Afterwards, we had a gathering of the same, plus a few extended family members for DD's baptism. We wanted both baptisms to be small and private, not a huge family event. DH's family has to have alcohol at every family gathering and drinking responsibly is not in their vocab. We didn't want all the drinking, so we didn't open up DS's baptism to extended family.