Atkins ? for a friend

Liz

Make a miracle!
Joined
Aug 18, 1999
Messages
4,909
I have a friend who lost a LOT of weight on Atkins. She went off the program for awhile and quickly gained back 20 lbs. She has been trying to start Atkins again but says its not working this time. Has anyone ever had that happen, where it quits working?

Also I was inviting her to come to WW with me if she decides to try something different. Do you think if she went to WW she would have a hard time losing initially after doing Atkins for a long time? I was thinking maybe since she'd be adding in carbs, etc. that maybe she'd gain even if she followed the program.

Thanks!
 
I went off Atkins after being on it for a long time and ended up being a size bigger than I ever was. I went on it last week and have already lost weight.
Your friend has to go back to the induction diet (the beginning stages) and be very strict with it. She should lose if she does that, I don't see how she can't.
Wishing her luck and willpower:D
 
I have a cousin who lost about 35 pounds on Atkins, quit for a while and then went back on and he could not get into ketosis no matter how hard he tried. Could it be that it affects different people in different ways?:confused:
 
I have heard that going back to Atkins is not always easy
i.e. stopping & starting can reduce effectiveness
 

I think your friend is going to have to add regular exercise to her weight loss plan - if she can find a way to include weight training in the plan (to build muscle), that should help a lot.

One of the problems with long term dieting (without exercise) is that it lowers metabolism. Your body adjusts to the lower number of calories and thus when you stop dieting and go back to more normal eating, you quickly gain weight. It's like your body is saying: "Starve me, and I'll just learn to do with less". That was a great "survival of the fittest" characteristic back when food was scarce, but it sure is a pain in the modern world, isn't it? (Too bad government doesn't work that way with our taxes, though. LOL)

One of the things I like about CURVES is that once you lose weight, it seems to stay off. The combination of aerobic exercise and weight training builds muscle. Muscles at rest take more calories than fat cells and muscles look much better under clothes than fat cells. :teeth: The other thing I like is that the exercise only takes about 30 minutes. I can do it in under an hour (from my front door back to my front door).

Recently, I just got back into the Curves routine. Previously, I lost about 10 pounds just doing Curves. Didn't change my eating habits or any of my daily routines. Lost about one pants size and even those were a little loose and look better on me now than they did when I was at that weight a "few years" ago. Stopped doing Curves but didn't gain back any weight. A miracle because I didn't adjust my eating habits or my daily routines after I quit. It's been about 9 months and this is the first time I've ever lost weight and kept it off. Trust me, that's a miracle!

I have just recently started back at Curves because I felt better when I was exercising. Planning to use their diet (which is similar to Atkins) because I want to lose 10 more pounds before my sister's wedding in June. Took me 4 or 5 months last time without dieting). Also, according to Curves, their diet isn't "a lifetime sentence". I tend to believe that based on my previous experience. However, I'm pretty sure that the ecercise part is "a lifetime sentence", LOL! But I hope it's one I can live with, because I really do feel better when exercise is in my life.

If anyone is still reading, thanks!

Liz - Hope your friend finds a way to lose weight that works for her. I really think adding exercise is the only way to go. Best wishes, Carol
 
The same thing happened to me - I lost 50 pounds on Atkins, and then got lazy and went back to my old, bad way of eating and gained almost all of it back!

I started back on Atkins and it didn't come off as fast, so I tried switching to WW. I lost about 2 pounds in a whole month. Very depressing. So, I went back to Atkins, and now I'm losing again! Yay!

WW just didn't work for me. I think it's becuase I eat so many carbs, that my body doesn't do well with them. WW was letting me eat way too many carbs and sugars, so I wasn't burning any fat!

Tell her to follow the Induction rules exactly, and she'll start seeing results!
 
I agree with Rhonda. Sounds like your friend should go back on induction and not deviate from that plan at all. She'll go back into ketosis.
 
Have her re-read the book so she is sure that she is completely on induction for at least 2 weeks.

If she'd like to post a couple days journals here --- it might be easier for us to pick out what she might want to add or eliminate.
:D
 



New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top