Yes, we've only been twice prior, so by no means a frequent guest! Our first stay was Oct 7th 2011 for a few nights which I admit will never be a proper stay. It had only been officially open a week and only one tower was open. The other stay was short as well. We have no children, so if you do, my opinion would not matter, frankly. The kids all seemed to be having a FANTASTIC time in the pool area and on the beach. What kind of trip are you doing..? My husband gives it a 6, I'd say 7. If we were owners or got to go more often I might rate it higher but I do feel like we missed out on things.
The problems I had with Aulani weren't really covid problems. You can't blame a visually dirty room on covid (if anything they claim to be cleaning BETTER). For how packed the pool area was at night they really should have enough lifeguards to keep the pools open later. Where else are we supposed to go? We saw several angry guests being told to get out of the river at 6pm... it was still light out. One gentleman stubbornly refused - we didn't stick around to watch how they handled that. Aside from some food items being out at 3pm (no chocolate bananas, a few other items out as well), Ama Ama being closed (we never ate there anyway) and seeing plexiglass around/facemask problems things seemed pretty much as I remembered them tbh. On paper having Waikolohe close at 6 and having to do the scavenager hunt before 7 sounded fine, but in reality we kept wanting to do things around then after dinner. Instead we had the option of watching stuff in our room, or getting on a waitlist for drinks. Even when we did get drinks the wind kept hitting the plexiglass barriers around the performers so they sounded like they were in a wind tunnel. It was still fun, but obviously it would have been MORE fun pre-covid.
As OKW Lover said it was a little weird having to show our vaccine cards on Oahu. On Maui the safe travels QR code was enough where they asked for anything, and not required for take away, but for some reason Oahu wanted the actual card and it didnt matter what we were there for. I didn't like carrying it - the card is an awkward size and problematic when I didn't want to carry a purse. I ended up putting it inside our fold up bluetooth keyboard, rubber banding it, and then tossing that in our snorkel bag. Thankfully we did not suffer a water mishap! We also had to give the name and phone number of someone in our party if we wanted to sit down. Many places we went weren't bothering - the tables were pushed to the side and chairs were up - they wanted you to take it away. Dukes did NOT handle their waiting area well at all. We were smooshed in there like sardines and waited about 25 minutes for a table. They were also taking drink orders so many people had their masks off in there while sipping.
FWIW when we checked in the CM assured us if the black band was annoying we could take it off and get a new one as often as we liked. We did not, as we didn't want to waste the plastic, but if it really annoys you it is an option.