Re:
When word spread it was a viable option for a cheaper way to get more days and more people started asking for it Disney pulled the plug.
I'm not certain it worked like that when more people started asking for it, because it had been available for quite some time, and even if others had not known they 'could' ask for more days, chances are pretty good that they did ask at the ticket gates. My point is it was going on for such a long time, I wonder why they would stop it later, rather than sooner.
We'll never know for sure why they stopped the $5 upgrade. What we do know is they stopped it when more and more people were finding out about it (just here on the DIS countless people found out about it), ticket fraud was at an all time high and DCA became a full day destination.
You have to keep in mind that Disney didn't EVER advertise the $5 upgrade, not at the ticket booths and not on line. If you where to call and inquire about an option past 6 days you were usually told what is being said now, buy more tickets or upgrade to an AP. In fact some ticket booth CMs refused to do it when asked even though they knew it was an option. Before when someone wanted to stay past their then 6 day ticket they wouldn't ask for the upgrade because they didn't know that it existed. What they would do is buy tickets at whatever the advertised price was. Might some have asked about special deals? Sure but I highly doubt it was more than an occasional occurance.
Just before the latest price hike I called DL about the $5 upgrade. My one daughter didn't think she'd be able to make the second trip this year so we thought we'd look into upgrading a max length hopper to 10 days. I had read about it here on the DIS. Been going to DL for 56 years and I didn't even know about it! I was first told she would need to buy two tickets that added up to 10 days. I then went into a bit more detail saying I had read on a Disney fan site that a 6 day could be upgraded for $5 to an 8 day and we were traveling from Chicago, etc. The CM put me on hold then came back and said that at the discretion of the ticket booth CM an upgrade to 8 days from 6 days was possible but not guarenteed, however upgrading to 10 days was not possible, so we'd still have to buy an additonal two day ticket even if they upgraded to a 6 day. We ended up just getting her the PAP in the end. Too many what ifs and I wanted to get the lower price before the increase. My best guess is that unless you knew someone that had actually gotten the $5 upgrade or read it on a fan site you either didn't know it existed or if you did and you were denied the upgrade you only got it if you were persistant. I recall very recently reading people were having to go to mutiple booths before they would find a CM willing to do the upgrade. Then the plug was pulled.
Re:
There are reports of scenes at the front gates almost daily with people being turned away for not having the right answers to questions they should know about when the ticket was first used. We witnessed several very ugly scene complete with children crying and adults swearing last month.
That is so sad, isn't it? The ugly scenes and the swearing. I feel badly for the kids whose parents tried to cut corners by purchasing from a non-legit source. The idea that they were supposed to know when the ticket was first used should have been their first clue that this policy was not right. Again, simply ensuring everyone has their names printed on tickets, with ID (school ID for kids, etc.) with random checks, would help to combat this problem, as would the biometrics others have spoken of. We've only noticed one incident at the gates in all the days we have been in the parks (probably 56 days, entering and exiting all of the time) but I don't doubt that it happens. Just that the percentage of fraudulent tickets is probably pretty low compared to annual sales. Not to mention, it is not a complete loss for them as they are still earning profit on food and merchandise from those who use those tickets. But in any event it is wrong for people to use those tickets. Disney can easily find a way to enforce that.
Sad for the children to not get to go into DL when they were told they would and for having to see their parents act like fools when they are denied entrance, yes. The adults are getting off easy by just having the transfered tickets confiscated. I wish what they were doing was considered an actual crime in Ca. that might curtail the transfering of tickets. People know when they are trying to cheat the system. They know they are breaking the non transferable rule yet they do it anyway. Trying to save money doesn't make it right or understandable. The sad reality is not everyone can afford to go to DL for even one day and it has been that way since it opened in 1955.
784 entrances (minimum) into DL for me since I first went in 1956. Up until maybe 5 years ago we rarely saw problems at the gates. The past 5 years have been a regular war zone at times. Guests screaming and swearing, children crying and on several occasions security escorting cheats away. Biometrics is probably the only viable resolution. My future SIL had a hopper when he joined us a few years ago to propose to my DD. The extra time it took for him to show ID was a real time hog in the entrance line. They were only doing spot checks back then so if they did it with everyone who had a paper ticket the line to get in would move at such a slow rate guests would be belly aching before they even got to the turnstyle.
Re:
I do believe once they get that problem taken care of we may see tickets for more than 5 days make a come back. Of course the price will be higher than the $5 upgrade but lower than what having to buy a 5 day ticket and a one, two or three day ticket on top of the 5 day currently is.
My whole argument is based on the fact that once you dish out so much money for a 5 day Park Hopper, the additional $5 per day for each day over was necessary to offer, or else people will still take their money elsewhere. The fact is, when a family of 4 spends $1080 to get into the park for 5 days, an estimate of $375 for daily food if 2 meals are eaten there, as well as souvenirs, candy, (fudge!!), cupcakes, CANDY CANES, etc., then I feel that it is a good thing for them to give their guests a little reprieve on the remaining days. Those who want 6 or 7 day Park Hopper passes IMO are more prone to taking longer breaks away at the pool, and so we don't make the Parks crowded all of the time. $1080 divided by 5 days means that each day is $216 for the family of 4. This is getting to be pretty extreme, IMO, as there are other options out there that a family can do with that money.
Hate to disagree with you, you seem like such a nice person, but I don't agree with this at all. It's close to $37 for a single person to see a first run movie and eat some snacks for two hours. I don't think 12 hours in the best theme park in the world should cost a day guest (that's what everyone is considered that isn't a AP) what it costs to see a movie and eat some snacks.
Also keep in mind that even though it is no longe possibler to go to DLR for $37 a day for 8 days it's still a saving of 44% over a one day hopper ticket at $70 per day.
Re:
Did Disney take it too far with eliminating everything over a 5 day pass? Of course they did but they are known for being so full of themselves that they over value their product to a fault. They did this big time when DCA first opened and were charging for an upgrade to have an AP that included DCA. They did back off on that and refunded the additonal costs to all that bought the AP that included DCA. I know this happened as we received the refund for our passes that year.
This means hope for us all, thank you for sharing this story! So... Disney was wrong about something, and they backed off and even refunded the difference back to their guests. I hope they will see that taking away a good thing for us (especially after raising the prices by so much 2 times during this past year) is a mistake, and then they will make good on it.
Yes they were wrong and they reacted quickly after DCA opened and it was apparent it was not what they claimed it would be.
I don't want to get your hopes up because what you all are dissapointed with is far different from what happened with the APs when DCA opened. What happened back then is Disney was charging more for less than advertised what you are trying to fight is Disney charging more for what they are now advertising and actually offering.
Re:
We made the leap to PAPs many years ago, and we live in the Chicagoland area. It was cheaper to get a PAP for a 10 day or more visit(s) than it was to buy mutiple tickets. and:
IMHO issuing 8 day park hopper tickets that ended up being $37 a day was pretty foolish of DLR. Currently even if one is doing two five day trips a year the cost of a PAP is still lower at $64 a day vs buying multiple tickets.
My argument above, about general cost overall, is an argument
against the idea that Disney was foolish to implement the 8 day Park Hopper. I don't think it was foolish at all, especially for those families who have to travel so far to get there. It was very much appreciated. The profit is still being made on tickets, as well as on food and merchandise, as well, they are maintaining their loyal customer base, ensuring their guests come back again and again. The price raise was bad enough, but taking away the option of extra days was really like a slap in the face. It's great for you to be able to get in on that annual pass, but many families (myself included) can not afford to fly on a family trip 2 times in a year.
For every guest that bulks at the current prices vs the old prices there is another guest willing to pay. They won't miss several hundred or even several thousand people not coming for an additional day or three. Now if you were talking several hundreds of thousands not coming at all then you've got their attention.
Let me say as a HUGE DLR fan I wasn't thrilled with the current PAP price hike. I made sure I renewed at the old price and will renew next year. If it takes scrimping and saving and cutting out other things in my life I'll do it. I'm a fan and I value what DLR has to offer.
Airfare is the smallest portion of my trips these days. With great offers from United and Southwest I haven't paid to fly to So Cal in the past three years. All you have to have is good credit and the willingness to open credit cards. Of course paying them off every month and not paying interest would be a given.
Re:
In the mean time there are alternatives, although they are not as cheap as the $5 upgarde. Buy a lower than PAP pass and go during times with little or no black out days. Go during Halloween and just do the parties on party days. Go during slower times when you can get more done in 5 days. Go to Disney for 5 days and enjoy other local attractions that are free or lower cost than DL. Of course you can just simply boycott Disney altogether but that isn't something I'd choose but in reality it is the one thing Disney would react to if it started to effect their numbers.
We always go during slower times, (off-season) however, we find that the wait lines are long as nothing is running at full capacity, such as only one track on BTMR, matterhorn, etc. So many times we have found we needed those extra days. We do find that it has not been uncrowded for a long time now. Those days are over. Going during Halloween isn't desirable for us, the Halloween crowds were hideous a couple of years ago. When we go to DL we want to BE at Disneyland, we don't want to try any other attractions, lol. I also wouldn't choose to boycott Disney altogether, but I could see us choosing to go maybe 1 week (oops, I mean 5 days) every 3 years unless they change this.
I can relate. We stay 17 days a year at the DLH and only go to DL and DCA. In the past 5 years we have snuck over to Knotts to eat at the CDR a couple of times but don't even bother with the actual theme park.
There is no way I could make it 3 years without a return trip. I barely make it from Oct to July without developing a twitch.
Re:
I hope everyone keeps fighting the good fight and Disney sees the error of their ways . I just wouldn't be holding my breathe for that $37 a day price for 8 day tickets to come back. I do hope I am wrong though.
Thank you for your support!!

I hope everyone keeps fighting this change too, so maybe Disney will see the error of their ways. I wouldn't mind seeing tickets as much as $10 more per day per person
Your welcome. I truely hope Disney does bring back tickets for a longer duration than just 5 days. I also hope those that want them will be thankful they did even if they are more than an additional $5 or $10 a day.
Good luck!
dsny1mom