Well, we're back and I didn't get to read your post before we left so we stayed at the Boardwalk Inn!
(When I called The Plaza Resort, they said they were 3 1/2 blocks away from the pier and it wasn't really walkable, which wasn't true. They were just on the other side of Ocean Walk. I think we would have liked it much better.)
Anyway, I completely agree with everything you said!!! The place was pretty much a mess and the pool and deck chairs needed some serious cleaning. I could also see how parking would be a nightmare if it was a busy time, and the stairways are still disgusting! Even though the people were very friendly, gave us an ocean front room for the price of a standard room and let us check in at 10 am, I don't think I'd stay there again.
I tried not to be a germ/clean freak and we managed to have a blast, LOL. The location was great, we were able to walk everywhere. We watched a storm come through from the pier which was pretty neat, and we ate at the Ocean Deck and The Wreck which were both excellent!
We've stayed at The Beachcomer Inn, which is inexpensive, casual and quaint, but now I think it's a palace, LOL. It's a mile and a half away from everything, but it's clean, there is always someone checking the pool, wiping the chairs and tables down, the snack bar is great and always open, there are towels and free pool toys and water wings, it's just a nice family place and all of the rooms are ocean front.
We also have reservations for the Ocean Walk in September, and after we stay there, I don't think I'll want to stay anywhere else, LOL!
Thanks so much for the info, maybe it will help someone else!