I would be too. If it is, pm me your address. I'm going to ship you an old dog toy, insure it for $100, and then file a claim. We can split the $100!!

Seriously, this isn't (more than likely) going to get paid by the USPS. Then the responsibility falls on the seller. Just because the money is already in his pocket, doesn't mean he can't file a claim with the cc company. Which he should've done in the first place.