Another incident to add to the "dolphins/whales in captivity in theme parks" debate

Status
Not open for further replies.

challer

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 6, 2008
Messages
1,264
Last week a false killer whale leapt from it's tank at the Churaumi Aquarium in Japan. You can see the other dolphins coming over to see! See the videos here:

http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi1.mov
http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi2.mov
http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi3.mov


Of course, Rick Barry of The Cove had something to say about it:

The Cove' Star Says Dolphin Video Shows Cruelty
'The Cove' Star Says Video Of Dolphin Leaping From Aquarium Tank Proves Captivity Is Cruel

(AP) TOKYO (AP) - The star of a film about Japanese dolphin hunting said Friday that new video footage showing a dolphin jumping out of an aquarium tank underlines the cruelty of captivity and demanded that all of the creatures be set free.

The startling footage of the dolphin, a species known as the false killer whale, shows the animal suddenly leaping out of a tank during a July 4 marine show at Okinawa Churaumi Aquarium, in southwestern Japan. An American tourist who was among the spectators shot the footage and sent it to Ric O'Barry.

O'Barry, 70, a former trainer for the "Flipper" TV show who now makes a career out of setting the animals free, made the videos available to The Associated Press.

In them, the dolphin lies on the floor. Workers wrap it in a mat and raise it by a crane to be placed back into the water. The other dolphins gather around the side of the tank.

O'Barry says the videos show a dolphin under stress.

"The habitat of that false killer whale is so unnatural it leaped out in desperation," he said in a telephone interview from Florida. "It wanted to end it. Why does a person jump out of a building?"

Hideshi Teruya, who manages the dolphin section of Churaumi, said the dolphin suffered minor scratches and bruises on its head and fin but was fine, and had a healthy appetite for mackerel and squid almost as soon as it was returned to a tank.

"It was playing around and jumped out by accident from the momentum," he told The Associated Press.

The age of the dolphin, a female named Kuru, which means "black" in Okinawan dialect, is unknown. It was captured about six years ago in the seas around Okinawa, Teruya said.

Teruya acknowledged that dolphins sometimes spring out and so he has placed mats around the tanks to prevent serious injury.

He denied the captivity was cruel, and said the tank was not overcrowded and followed general aquarium guidelines.

O'Barry believes such guidelines are inadequate. Dolphins are used to roaming for many miles a day, not swimming in a circle and doing flips at shows, he said.

Sound is the most important sense for dolphins. So keeping them in a concrete box is cruel, bombarding the animal with strange sounds and depriving a key sensory skill, according to O'Barry.

"It proves that captivity doesn't work," he said of the videos. "They are free-ranging creatures with a very large brain. They're self aware and putting them in a small tank in a stadium setting is abusive."

O'Barry said many other animals, including snakes, tend to get zoo cages that look more like their natural habitat than do dolphins.

"Release all of them and find a cruelty-free way of making a living," he said.

"The Cove" depicts O'Barry's efforts to stop the slaughter of dolphins for food in the Japanese town of Taiji. It uses hidden cameras to show how the dolphins are killed, being herded into a cove and pierced with spears as they bleed and writhe in the water.

The film, which won best documentary at this year's Academy Awards, opened at theaters in Japan this month despite protests and threats by nationalists, who say the work ridicules Japanese culture.

___

On the Net:

Video downloads of the dolphin from O'Barry:

http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi1.mov

http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi2.mov

http://benweiss.com/pages/docs/churaumi/churaumi3.mov
 
This video is very sad to see,but i hope rick barry can make a difference.

I watched the cove last week,heart breaking

But Rick Barry was right to make the doc,it changed my view on sea life parks like Seaworld and the japanese.

Not sure if seaworld will ever see any of my money again.
I love seaworld,it had to be my favourite park.

Being from the uk,we dont have anything like this,And its a real shame that when the camera is on seaworld they look like there helping,but behind closed doors theres a real darkside

For all UK dissers
The Cove is being show or the (MORE 4) TV CHANNEL 15/7/10 AT 10pm and will be repeated over the next week or so.
 
For all UK disers
The Cove is being show or the (MORE 4) TV CHANNEL 15/7/10 AT 10pm and will be repeated over the next week or so.

Yes! Good call. I recommend you see the whole film - even if it is difficult to watch.
 
For all UK dissers
The Cove is being show or the (MORE 4) TV CHANNEL 15/7/10 AT 10pm and will be repeated over the next week or so.

Thanks, I will keep an eye out for it!

I have recently revised my view of seaworld after my visit in June, I will not be returning.
 

Wow poor thing that is not a very big tank it probably was trying to get out.

Anyone else find it interesting that the others in the tank came over and watched?
 
Wow poor thing that is not a very big tank it probably was trying to get out.

Anyone else find it interesting that the others in the tank came over and watched?

I noticed that in video #2 - I was nervous that the others were going to follow!
 
/
Chad, not to add fuel to the fire, but why is this titled "SeaWorld Cruelty"? Besides the fact that SeaWorld is also a marine mammal park, what did they have to do with this dolphin jumping out of the tank?
 
Chad, not to add fuel to the fire, but why is this titlted "SeaWorld Cruelty"? Besides the fact that SeaWorld is also a marine mammal park, what did they have to do with this dolphin jumping out of the tank?

Based on previous threads, discussions about the accident at Sea World, discussions about the Cove, etc. It has been a discussion before - because of the Orlando-centricity of the boards, it tends to focus on Sea World.
 
i haven't watched the videos...

the description is difficult enough for me to read...

it's very upsetting..

one of these days, i'll write up my thoughts about the behind the scenes tour i took at epcot a few weeks ago - dolphins in depth....
i was very hesitant to take the tour as the fact that 4 dolphins are living in an enclosed tank really disturbs me..

but i decided to take the tour to see for myself (rather than base my opinions on conjecture)..
 
Based on previous threads, discussions about the accident at Sea World, discussions about the Cove, etc. It has been a discussion before - because of the Orlando-centricity of the boards, it tends to focus on Sea World.
True, but when I read the title it made it seem as though SeaWorld had something to do with this particular incident which I thought was misleading. I certainly understand why you posted it, and know that we have had many discussions on the topic before (of which I have participated in a little). However, SeaWorld has nothing to do with this particular incident, correct?
 
True, but when I read the title it made it seem as though SeaWorld had something to do with this particular incident which I thought was misleading. I certainly understand why you posted it, and know that we have had many discussions on the topic before (of which I have participated in a little). However, SeaWorld has nothing to do with this particular incident, correct?

Correct. Sea World had nothing to do with this particular incident. That is why I referred to the Sea World debate - not Sea World.

Unless one feels that this relates to the whole "whale/dolphin in captivity for entertainment/theme park purposes" idea. Then Sea World could be connected to this, as they are the largest player and leaders of the industry.

But specifically? No. Sea World is not a part of this.
 
i haven't watched the videos...

the description is difficult enough for me to read...

it's very upsetting..

one of these days, i'll write up my thoughts about the behind the scenes tour i took at epcot a few weeks ago - dolphins in depth....
i was very hesitant to take the tour as the fact that 4 dolphins are living in an enclosed tank really disturbs me..

but i decided to take the tour to see for myself (rather than base my opinions on conjecture)..

The good thing about the videos: the dolphin was saved. But it is still disturbing.

I'm very curious to hear your thoughts on the tour.
 
I agree with Dave.

This has nothing to do with Sea World and the title of the thread is inflammatory.

This is something our local news would do and I find it a bit irresponsible.

I understand that there is an agenda here and that using the Sea World name gets people to read the accompanying material.

Our local news runs headlines frequently with things like "Death at Disney" and you find that there has been a traffic fatality on I-4 20 miles from Disney.....but that's what grabs peoples attention.

It's a bit of a cheap ploy.
 
I agree with Dave.

This has nothing to do with Sea World and the title of the thread is inflammatory.

This is something our local news would do and I find it a bit irresponsible.

I understand that there is an agenda here and that using the Sea World name gets people to read the accompanying material.

Our local news runs headlines frequently with things like "Death at Disney" and you find that there has been a traffic fatality on I-4 20 miles from Disney.....but that's what grabs peoples attention.

It's a bit of a cheap ploy.

I apologize. I just felt that the subject line: Another incident to the "Dolphins/whales in captivity for amusement in theme parks" debate was a bit cumbersome. And, yes, I also used SW to get people's attention, but not to disparrage SW in any way - just to get people who have been interested in this discussion (which has been primarily about SW before) to see this as a possible related story.

Sorry if it was misleading, or if I offended Sea World fans in any way.

I don't know how to do this - is there a way to go back and edit a thread title?
 
i haven't watched the videos...

the description is difficult enough for me to read...

it's very upsetting..

one of these days, i'll write up my thoughts about the behind the scenes tour i took at epcot a few weeks ago - dolphins in depth....
i was very hesitant to take the tour as the fact that 4 dolphins are living in an enclosed tank really disturbs me..

but i decided to take the tour to see for myself (rather than base my opinions on conjecture)..

I really hope you do Beth! I would love to hear your thoughts on it, as it is something I would like to do myself.

From the 10 minute talk at Disney, I felt I did gain a lot more information about the animals than I did in a whole day at Seaworld, but I would love to hear what the tours were like- maybe even do a segment on it!
 
This video is very sad to see,but i hope rick barry can make a difference.

I watched the cove last week,heart breaking

But Rick Barry was right to make the doc,it changed my view on sea life parks like Seaworld and the japanese.

Not sure if seaworld will ever see any of my money again.
I love seaworld,it had to be my favourite park.

Being from the uk,we dont have anything like this,And its a real shame that when the camera is on seaworld they look like there helping,but behind closed doors theres a real darkside

For all UK dissers
The Cove is being show or the (MORE 4) TV CHANNEL 15/7/10 AT 10pm and will be repeated over the next week or so.

thank you for not visiting seaworld again.
i liked seaworld too - but when i saw this doc - broke my heart.
i always wanted to swim with a dolphin - but now i know i can't as it is just plain wrong. x
 
Thanks, I will keep an eye out for it!

I have recently revised my view of seaworld after my visit in June, I will not be returning.

thank you.
the only way to stop this is to not buy an admission ticket. x
 
have you heard of lolia captured in 1970 and kept in a tiny tank in miami:

'Lolita is a 42 year old captive killer whale (orca) living at the Miami Seaquarium in Florida. Since her brutal capture in 1970, she has been kept in a tank that is illegal by the Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) standards for size requirements. Lolita is approximately 21 feet long and 7,000 pounds. Her tank is 20 feet deep at the deepest point and a mere 12 feet deep around the edges. The pool is only 35 feet wide. The Miami Seaquarium is considered to be one of the most dilapidated aquatic parks in the world. It is in need of major repairs, and per the Marine Mammal Inventory Report, has a substantial death rate for their animals.'

http://www.savelolita.com/

TRAGIC.:sad1:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.





New Posts









Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top