I'm from New York and have been a fan of Ample Hills for years. A location is opening a short walk from my apartment literally next week! Everything's good there, but I'm particularly a fan of the butter cake flavor.
I tasted Nonna D's at the Boardwalk. If I got a sampler, it would be one of my picks. But the one time I've been there, I wanted just a cup of one flavor and couldn't resist the Baked/Unbaked.