American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[JDUCKY]

She should have gone the soulful, haunting route like The Sundays did when they did Wild Horses

I agree w/Simon that the last half kinda went awry.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

i can't hate on Tim Urban....he's just too cute!

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

I think it is really not fair to have them sing songs from a group that has such a strong presence in music. They are so well known and Mick is so well known for his stage persona that nothing is going to sound as good or better than the original.

Yeah, I agree. It falls into the same type of category as no Whitney or Mariah songs.

 

[charming23]

Are the judges watching the same performances as we are? I did not think Katie was that good. Wild Horses is such a classic song and she did not do it justice.

 

[StephyDee]

I kinda wish someone would've done "I Can't Get No Satisfaction".....that would connect with the audience for sure!

I just want someone to not suck. That's all I ask.

 

[Robinrs]

I think she has a nice voice...I just don't think she has a voice to be making pop/rock albums. She seems too practiced and studied and not just singing and having a good time.

I think that's what bugs me about her. Mike on EW says she's like a wind up doll.

 

[JDUCKY]

Sorry I'm late tonight...was reading a great book


Um, well, not really. More like the inside of my eyelids!

 

[Nancy]

Robin...I'm not hating tonight either. BUT Tim is singing one of the few Stones songs I really like so that could change.

I don't really like the Stones so I myself haven't minded the songs so far.

 

[chisnpeke]

I think she has a nice voice...I just don't think she has a voice to be making pop/rock albums. She seems too practiced and studied and not just singing and having a good time.

This is how I feel too. Not a pop voice.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Hubby switched it over to Lost. Although I'm pretty sure all of your posts will be more entertaining then the actual show.

more entertaining than Lost?? anything's more entertaining than that show....i stopped watching back in season 3.

 

[WDWRocksMySocks]

omg yes!!! that's where i heard it!! it was the prom episode, they were dancing to it!! i loved that cover!

YES!!! I loved it!!!!

 

[StephyDee]

i can't hate on Tim Urban....he's just too cute!

For sure! May not have the best voice, but he's not bad to look at either.

 

[krcit]

I read that Aaron is singing Angie That's my all-time favorite song, not just Stones song. I am scared!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I kinda wish someone would've done "I Can't Get No Satisfaction".....that would connect with the audience for sure!

I just want someone to not suck. That's all I ask.

 

[java]

Why are they slowing them all down. This is putting me to sleep. Under My Thumb is brutal.

 

[kimmar067]

...Bob Marley reincarnated...

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

YES!!! I loved it!!!!

that episode was just on earlier today, actually lol. i miss that show so much

For sure! May not have the best voice, but he's not bad to look at either.

exactly. he's just too cute, even if this song is really boring

 

[Nancy]

Not hating the reggae version....His voice is doing good with the song this way

 

[JDUCKY]

Under My Thumb with more of a reggae meets Las Vegas lounge twist.


Interesting.


If it was under *my* thumb I'd probably squish it.

 

[StephyDee]

What the? Unless I was just seeing things, Tim's fingernails were long....like girlish long.