American Idol Season 9 Thread Top 5

[mandy200587]

Here we go guys new home, let's get to top 3 before we need a new mmk?

 

[StephyDee]

I'm here!

 

[Cat0727]

I'm here!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

i think we get more excited to talk in this thread than to listen to anyone even sing at this point. i think that's why we keep going thru the threads so fast

 

[ShuisFan584]

I made it just in time for the new thread!

Sorry I wasn't around tonight. I was at my mom's house writing a whole bunch of thank you notes before American Idol (and still not close to being done blahhh) and just got home now.

I thought Lee and Aaron were the best tonight. This was the first time I really liked Lee.

I thought Crystal was good but it wasn't her best.

I thought Casey was terrible. I guess that's why he needs his guitar every week. He'll be in trouble tomorrow.

I thought Mike was annoying. And then I thought he was more annoying after the judges praised him. At least they thought one person was better than him. I guess he'll be around another week.

 

[StephyDee]

i think we get more excited to talk in this thread than to listen to anyone even sing at this point. i think that's why we keep going thru the threads so fast

LOL IKR?

Didn't we get the first one closed down only like 3-4 weeks ago? That means we go through like 62 pages of the thread PER WEEK!



and allllllllllll worth it!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I made it just in time for the new thread!

Sorry I wasn't around tonight. I was at my mom's house writing a whole bunch of thank you notes before American Idol (and still not close to being done blahhh) and just got home now.

I thought Lee and Aaron were the best tonight. This was the first time I really liked Lee.

I thought Crystal was good but it wasn't her best.

I thought Casey was terrible. I guess that's why he needs his guitar every week. He'll be in trouble tomorrow.

I thought Mike was annoying. And then I thought he was more annoying after the judges praised him. At least they thought one person was better than him. I guess he'll be around another week.

we all kind of knew Casey wasn't going to stick around for very long. it honestly wouldn't surprise me if he left. altho i WOULD like to see Mike leave before anyone else......

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

LOL IKR?

Didn't we get the first one closed down only like 3-4 weeks ago? That means we go through like 62 pages of the thread PER WEEK!



and allllllllllll worth it!

at least it's some form of entertainment lol

 

[ShuisFan584]

we all kind of knew Casey wasn't going to stick around for very long. it honestly wouldn't surprise me if he left. altho i WOULD like to see Mike leave before anyone else......

I wish Mike would have gone weeks ago when he should have. He's too annoying to me. So is his wife.

 

[StephyDee]

this is my order of who should be kicked off next.

1: Mike - ASAP! That 'save' he had just gave him 10,000 lbs of ego and 0 lbs of more talent. He's good, but.....he was voted off for a reason.

2: Casey - he was cute at first, but now he's starting to get to me. It's like he crashing a party, where he isn't supposed to be there, but he's fun, so somehow he stays, ticking off many people while others enjoy his company.

3: Aaron - nice kid, but he just doesn't have the pipes. He's like 80% there though, and improving, but not fast enough for this season.

#4 and 5 can be either Lee or Crystal in either spot, but I kinda want Lee to win, just to prove all the Crystal-lovers wrong. Kinda like how last season went with Kris and Adam. Lee's really good, so it won't be so farfetched.

That's just me though.

 

[aprilgail2]

I like Casey but he was terrible tonight.
Big Mike- YUK
Crystal- Not good
Aaron- ok
Lee was the best tonight- I don't think I ever liked him best before!

 

[ShuisFan584]

this is my order of who should be kicked off next.

1: Mike - ASAP! That 'save' he had just gave him 10,000 lbs of ego and 0 lbs of more talent. He's good, but.....he was voted off for a reason.

2: Casey - he was cute at first, but now he's starting to get to me. It's like he crashing a party, where he isn't supposed to be there, but he's fun, so somehow he stays, ticking off many people while others enjoy his company.

3: Aaron - nice kid, but he just doesn't have the pipes. He's like 80% there though, and improving, but not fast enough for this season.

#4 and 5 can be either Lee or Crystal in either spot, but I kinda want Lee to win, just to prove all the Crystal-lovers wrong. Kinda like how last season went with Kris and Adam. Lee's really good, so it won't be so farfetched.

That's just me though.

That would be exactly my order! Although I have a feeling it won't be Mike tomorrow. But he has outlasted his stay.

Even in the top 24 I thought Casey was ok. But since the top 24 was so weak, he was basically one of the best. There's no way he would have made it this far in any other season.

But as far as who wins, I don't like either of them enough to really care that much.

 

[TreslovesWDW]

Will someone post the order so I can still vote I had to miss the show tonite

 

[bunkkinsmom]

i made it

 

[StephyDee]

Will someone post the order so I can still vote I had to miss the show tonite

I responded to you in the other thread, but here's the order: Aaron, Casey, Crystal, Mike, and Lee.

and the number is 1-866-436-5701 to 5705, depending on who you vote for.

 

[TreslovesWDW]

Thank you again,I though I would go to the new thread incase no one was on the other...

 

[StephyDee]

Thank you again,I though I would go to the new thread incase no one was on the other...

lol not a problem. I'm checking on both just in case people are straggling in the other one. I DID leave a pretty big note there for them to see though.

 

[lillygator]

I am impressed at how much Harry worked with them all.

 

[Mean Queen]

Found you! I voted for Crystal and Lee. Just wasn't impressed with anyone else.

 

[Bluestars]

I hope Mike goes next. He should never have been saved.

Then I hope it's:
Aaron
Casey

and Crystal & Lee are the final two, with Lee winning.

I thought this one of the worst weeks so far, song-wise.