American Idol Season 6: The Official Thread

[Pig Pen]

My final tally:

#1 Sundance
#2 Chris S.
#3 Phil
#4 Blake
#5 AJ
#6 Jared
#7 Chris R
#8 Nick
#9 Brandon
#10 Sanjaya

But I think Brandon & Nick will be going home.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

Wow....thats funny, because I thought they were ALL good. Not one dud in the bunch imo.

i guess i'm just picky lol

 

[Sandy22]

I liked Sundance's singing but I hated the band's arrangement and the back-up singers.

 

[Nancy]

This week was so much better than last week.

The weakest today?

Brandon, Nick and Sanjaya

and I think Nick and Sanjaya should say bye bye.

 

[Robinrs]

Sundance! Dude! You worked it OUT!!

....sorry, channeling my Randy Jackson spirit..

 

[Ticket Man]

My final tally:

#1 Sundance
#2 Chris S.
#3 Phil
#4 Blake
#5 AJ
#6 Jared
#7 Chris R
#8 Nick
#9 Brandon
#10 Sanjaya

But I think Brandon & Nick will be going home.

My Rankings:

#1. Sundance: John Popper meets Taylor Hicks, I loved it.
2. Phil Stacey: Better than the original, a great choice, a great voice, and a solider, great combo!
3. Chris R.: So far he's only sung songs Elliott sang last year + this song by a Richmond native, gotta love it here in VA.
4. Blake: Awesome performance, showed his own originality in an awesome song.


BIG GAP BETWEEN 4 and 5

5. Jared: This song is so great that it's easy to make it sound good, he did just ok with it.
6. Chris S: Somewhat boring, but he had a good vocal performance.
7. Brandon: He sounded a little wimpy, but it was a good choice, and an average performance.
8. AJ: I didn't like it, a somewhat generic choice and a boring performance.
9. Nick: Ehhh, he has no personality and a bland voice, this did nothing for me.
10. Sanjaya: Just terrible, it was like spoken word by Michael Jackson to 40s music.

 

[JunieJay]

My picks:

1. Blake
2. Chris S.
3. Chris R.
4. Sundance
5. Nick
6. Jared
7. Brandon
8. AJ
9. Phil
10.. Sanjaya

I'd like to see Sanjaya and Phil go home, but I'm positive Phil won't be going - he'll be this year's miltary man, just like that kid who got to the top 4 the year Carrie was the winner....his name escapes me now. If Sanjaya doesn't go, something is seriously wrong with the voting system.

 

[dolphindan1]

My picks:

1. Blake
2. Chris S.
3. Chris R.
4. Sundance
5. Nick
6. Jared
7. Brandon
8. AJ
9. Phil
10.. Sanjaya

I'd like to see Sanjaya and Phil go home, but I'm positive Phil won't be going - he'll be this year's miltary man, just like that kid who got to the top 4 the year Carrie was the winner....his name escapes me now. If Sanjaya doesn't go, something is seriously wrong with the voting system.

You are referring to Josh Gracin....we saw him and met him at concert....wonderful person....I agree with you about the voting system too....Sanjaya needs to go home...as do AJ or Nick

 

[Pig Pen]

If Sanjaya doesn't go, something is seriously wrong with the voting system.[/QUOTE]

The teeny bopper girls will love him I'm afraid....

 

[lillygator]

If Sanjaya doesn't go, something is seriously wrong with the voting system.

The teeny bopper girls will love him I'm afraid....

what teeny boppers? I would be all over Richardson or Blake...

 

[Sandy22]

10. Sanjaya: Just terrible, it was like spoken word by Michael Jackson to 40s music.

That's a perfect description! I hope he goes home. His stage presence is so awkward it's uncomfortable to watch.

 

[dolphindan1]

The teeny bopper girls will love him I'm afraid....

what teeny boppers? I would be all over Richardson or Blake...[/QUOTE]

I was thinking the same thing....I would hate to see a great voice like Brandon go home over a flawed voting system....but I guess it happens every year....

 

[Snow_White]

The teeny bopper girls will love him I'm afraid....

what teeny boppers? I would be all over Richardson or Blake...[/QUOTE]

The older teeny boppers will like those 2, but the really young teeny boppers (I'm talking 10-12 year olds here) LOVE Sanjaya. Unfortunately, that is.

 

[dolphindan1]

I think if Brandon goes home i am gonna start shouting racism....and i am a poor white guy from South Carolina...and being from South Carolina you know we are not race friendly....LOL...He needs to stay

 

[Ticket Man]

Gideon last year was MUCH better than Brandon and he went home at this stage. Sanjaya has got to go though.

 

[Sandy22]

My order of favorites:

1. Chris S.
2. Blake
3. Brandon
4. Sundance
5. Jared
6. Chris R.
7. Phil
8. AJ
9. Nick
10. Sanjaya

Hoping for Nick and Sanjaya to go home. But I'm worried Brandon will leave instead of Sanjaya.

 

[dolphindan1]

what teeny boppers? I would be all over Richardson or Blake...

The older teeny boppers will like those 2, but the really young teeny boppers (I'm talking 10-12 year olds here) LOVE Sanjaya. Unfortunately, that is.[/QUOTE]

well that age group should be in bed on a school night at this hour and if they were up they better not be all over the phone....I know my 10 year old son is in bed at 8:30 every school night

 

[dolphindan1]

what the number for Brandon...I have never voted but I think I will start tonight

 

[Eeyore's Buddy Bear]

Brandon's number is 1-866-IDOLS-08

I agree that he has a wonderful voice. I have voted for him, and I didn't get any busy signals.

 

[aprilgail2]

well that age group should be in bed on a school night at this hour and if they were up they better not be all over the phone....I know my 10 year old son is in bed at 8:30 every school night

My 7 year old watches with me every night (she also watched that Game show after it tonight) and she didn't like Sanjaya either, she said he is "creepy looking". She was on the phone voting for blake!