American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[Slacking]

Jose (refuse to call him by stupid name) was AWFUL!

I thought Will was fantastic! I can't believe Kevin got more positive comments than Will did.

 

[Pig Pen]

I am hoping that Bucky really belts one out.

 

[kdibattista]

I have to say... I'm just gonna come out and say it... I can't believe I'm admitting this...

I think Bucky's HOT!!!!! But only with his hair pulled back and when he's not talking

 

[Pig Pen]

1= worse, 10= best

Taylor - 7
Elliott - 8
Ace - 5
Gedeon - 8
Kevin (or is it Chicken Little?) is next.....

Kevin - 3
Sway - 2
Ryan - 6
Bucky - 5

next are David and CHRIS!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

Now that is how I like David!

 

[Pig Pen]

I have to say... I'm just gonna come out and say it... I can't believe I'm admitting this...

I think Bucky's HOT!!!!! But only with his hair pulled back and when he's not talking

I agree! His voice is very annoying....not because he is southern, but there is something else there that bugs me. But I am surprised at how good he looks when he is on stage.

 

[Pig Pen]

I think the Sinatra stuff is going to get old very quickly.

 

[Slacking]

Who is this Ryan that people are rating? I think you mean Will.

 

[Pig Pen]

Chris is going to rock!!!!!!

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

Who is this Ryan that people are rating? I think you mean Will.

Are we rating the host now?

 

[kdibattista]

I think Chris is going to take the whole thing

 

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

Chris ROCKED tonight!!

 

[ntburns22]

Chris has my vote!

 

[Pig Pen]

Not my favorite song but I think he was awesome.

Simon says this was the best!

 

[BARBARAAPPLE]

I hope the hometown boy takes it
GO CHRIS

 

[kikakeko]

Holy crap are you all watching AI now? We are getting basketball no AI till 10:30 here in OH no fair...

 

[Pig Pen]

sorry....yes it's Will. I am confused.

 

[Andrea]

im still voting for Taylor he's my favorite

 

[LadyBears]

DDDaaaammmnnnn!!!! Chris nailed it tonight!! He was sooo awesome!

If that was out as a single - I would buy it!!

I missed most of tonights shows, but from what I did see & the recaps - I have to say Chris & Bucky were the 2 best tonight!

 

[Sandy22]

1. Taylor – it was good but it wasn’t great. I liked last week’s performance better

2. Elliot – Awesome!

3. Ace – I cringed through that one. Lucky for him, his good looks are going to carry him through another week.

4. Gedeon – Oh wow! That caught me by surprise! I loved it – it was awesome. Just my personal opinion but I think his voice sounds a little too refined/polished. I like male vocalists who sound a little rough around the edges.

5. Kevin – just average vocals. He’s too boyish for me…I want to hear from the MEN!

6. Sway – better than last week but he had trouble staying on key. I think he’s going home. I agree with Simon – very kareoke

7. Will – he’s not very attractive when he sings with his mouth open. On to the important stuff, he impressed me tonight! Much better than last week. I think he’ll just make it through to the next week.

8. Bucky – Hooooweee! Loved the performance. Great voice – love the country rock vibe.

9. David – another surprise performance! Really liked it! But I don’t think he can sing in any other genre. I think he’ll squeak through another week.

10. Chris – AWESOME!!! Paula looked like she was about to jump him! Can't say I blame the girl!

Top picks: 1-Chris, 2-Giddeon, 3-Taylor, 4-Bucky

Bottom 3: Sway, Kevin, David