American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[J.Cooper]

Katherine sung a Stevie Wonder song. She sounded terrible to me. Wasn't the right song choice. So far Katherine & Kinnick performances have been blah!

 

[Robinrs]

I missed Katherines song..what did she sing? Kinnicks song I did not like..I wasn't too crazy about the original, not a good song choice for her.

Katherine sang "All Is Fair In Love" by Stevie Wonder.

 

[Philadisney]

i wasn't too into lisa either. i think she has a wonderful voice and is incredibly talented, but her personality doesn't do it for me. a little too polished, "child star" for me.
but i LOVED melissa (and i don't usually enjoy country music)! i love her smoky voice, and i think she has a great personality! so far she's the first to make me look up at my TV and say 'wow!' she'll get my vote tonight

 

[dopeys biggest fan]

These girls are boring the crap out of me! What happened to this show??

 

[Robinrs]

Yikes! I'm doing something different, LISTENING to the show without looking at the people... I feel like I'm sitting in an awful Kareoke bar!!!

No one is a stand out YET.... Heather stabbed herself in the toe with that Mariah song...who's next????

 

[Slacking]

Nobody (through Heather) has impressed me too much so far. Melissa was ok, everyone else wasn't.

Come on Brenna, turn everything around!

 

[Robinrs]

Yikes! I'm doing something different, LISTENING to the show without looking at the people... I feel like I'm sitting in an awful Kareoke bar!!!

No one is a stand out YET.... Heather stabbed herself in the toe with that Mariah song...who's next????

OOOOH NOOOOO.... BRENNA!!!!

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

I agree, Melissa was the best so far-but I am totally bored-bring on the guys!!! Brenna is on and she could sing like an angel and I would still not like her. I missed 1/2 the show last week,cause of work, and I wish I had done the same thing this week. The recaps would have been plenty.

 

[J.Cooper]

The girls are blah tonight. Ms. Diva (Brenna) needs to come off her high horse! She thinks she is really hot?

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

Do they not KNOW "who" they are talking to?LOL-I am so glad she was bad!!! And maybe we are done with her.

 

[damo]

Nobody (through Heather) has impressed me too much so far. Melissa was ok, everyone else wasn't.

Come on Brenna, turn everything around!

MUTE! MUTE!!! WHERE'S MY MUTE BUTTON???!!!!

You'd better vote hard tonight Slacking!

 

[dopeys biggest fan]

http://www.brandens.net/files/Sounds/FX/Animals/WILD_DOG.WAV

 

[Robinrs]

Awful, just awful...

I'm turning into SIMON tonight!! Bad Bad... bring on the guys tomorrow night!!

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

Dopey-that was perfect!!! LOL

 

[Poohbear123]

Awful, just awful...

I'm turning into SIMON tonight!! Bad Bad... bring on the guys tomorrow night!!

I Agree! But, Paris is NEXT!

 

[Slacking]

MUTE! MUTE!!! WHERE'S MY MUTE BUTTON???!!!!

You'd better vote hard tonight Slacking!

You better believe I'm ready!!!!

I fear shes gone this week though

 

[Nancy]

These girls are boring the crap out of me! What happened to this show??

Why doesn't someone tell them their song choices suck?

I did enjoy Melissa tonight though.

Brenna....yuck, yuck, yuck...I am so sick of the posing and the "look at me attitude"

 

[J.Cooper]

Thank God Amazing Race is coming on in 1 minute. Bye-Bye American Idol.

 

[twoksmom]

I agree.April

 

[JoenAdamnErinnSam]

She gave me chills-I love that song though, she's gonna be tough to beat with the other performances.