American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[damo]

Thank God Amazing Race is coming on in 1 minute. Bye-Bye American Idol.

I thought AR was on after Idol???

 

[kitn]

I was beginning to think my lack of sleep was making me think everyone sounds bad. I am glad people agree with me this is quite boring tonight.

 

[Robinrs]

Paris sang one of my FAVORITE songs... I guess I'm the same age as her Great Grandma...

I actually dedicated it to my Dad on his 80th birthday. .... chills....

The only smile I got tonight...

 

[Slacking]

Damo, Tonight AI and TAR overlap for TAR's first half-hour.

I am DVRing TAR and will watch it while voting for Brenna

 

[palmtreegirl]

We're watching on DVR and so far Lisa is the only one that was decent but what the heck was she wearing?

 

[damo]

Damo, Tonight AI and TAR overlap for TAR's first half-hour.

I am DVRing TAR and will watch it while voting for Brenna

SHOOOOOOT!!!

 

[dopeys biggest fan]

We're watching on DVR and so far Lisa is the only one that was decent but what the heck was she wearing?

Trust me dude, don't waste your time........ Switch to the Amazing Race!!!

 

[palmtreegirl]

Trust me dude, don't waste your time........ Switch to the Amazing Race!!!

I hate commercials so I'm waiting for The Amazing race to be at least an hour into it before I start watching.

 

[dopeys biggest fan]

I hate commercials so I'm waiting for The Amazing race to be at least an hour into it before I start watching.

Green with envy over your dang DVR......Cheap DH!

 

[palmtreegirl]

Who dressed most of these girls? AI needs to invest in some full length mirrors, seriously most of them looked terrible.

I liked Kellie, cute outfit too.

 

[Rafiki Rafiki Rafiki]

Can someone please give me the order in which the girls sang tonight or point me towards a site where I can get their numbers?

The idol site doesn't seem to have it.

 

[cheeringmom]

I agree with just about everyone

 

[RyMickey]

This is my first post on AI this season, and I figure I've gotta start sometime, despite the fact that I thought that this night was poor all around.

At this point, my favorites are Katharine, Mandisa, and Paris. None of those ladies did all that well tonight, though. I could take or leave all the others.

The worst tonight without a doubt were the obnoxious Brenna and Heather and despite the fact that Brenna is a hoot to watch, I honestly can't stand her anymore (not that I ever could).

Just my two little $.02 tonight...

 

[damo]

Ack, that was a waste of an hour and a half!!! Bring on the guys!!!

Brenna was the only one that was a trainwreck but no one earned the Idol crown tonight. I would predict that Brenna and Heather are gone as well.

 

[aprilgail2]

wow, tonights show could have put me to sleep...none of them sang any song to get the people up moving thats for sure...it like a snooze fest!!!!

 

[Rafiki Rafiki Rafiki]

Hello...can anyone put the singers in order for singing tonight? Please?!

I know these:
Katherine 01
Brenna 06
Kellie 09
Mandisa 10

but I really don't know about Melissa, Paris, Lisa, and the other three...

 

[Eeyore's Buddy Bear]

Here are the numbers for tonight:

01 - Katharine McPhee
02 - Kinnik Sky
03 - Lisa Tucker
04 - Melissa McGhee
05 - Heather Cox
06 - Brenna Gethers
07 - Paris Bennett
08 - Ayla Brown
09 - Kellie Pickler
10 - Mandisa

 

[damo]

1. Katharine -
2. Kinnik -
3. Lisa -
4. Melissa -
5. Heather -
6. Brenna -
7. Paris -
8. Ayla -
9. Kellie
10. Mandisa

 

[Brianne]

What a yawn fest. And I can't say what I want to say about Brenna on here without being banned, but I will say I can only hope she's going home Thursday. I'll be dancing around the living room if she does!

Let's bring on the guys! My money's on them now.

 

[Rafiki Rafiki Rafiki]

Thanks guys. I've voted my little heart out tonight...