American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[*NikkiBell*]

Why ON EARTH can't this dingaling girl sing something NEW?

 

[disney1990]

Sorry, I just don't like the way that Kat sings Somewhere over the Rainbow.

 

[WDWLVR]

Katherine #2 - I don't think this is as good as her first number. I didn't care for it when she sang it last time either.

 

[kdibattista]

Wow... Kat's not doing to well with #2. Not nearly as good as her first time around with it.

Those people really have to stop waving

 

[Robinrs]

Boy she sure decided to stick with "safe", huh?

 

[MickeyMouseGal]

I don't get it. Kat's second version of this song wasn't nearly as good as last time... yet the judges didn't seem to notice.

 

[Poohbear123]

I don't get it. Kat's second version of this song wasn't nearly as good as last time... yet the judges didn't seem to notice.

OH, she sang, I am sorry, I had the TV on MUTE.....

 

[disney1990]

Simon wouldn't have noticed. It was the song he picked for her.

 

[Reflection]

Katherine #2 - I don't think this is as good as her first number. I didn't care for it when she sang it last time either.

I didn't care for Over the Rainbow last time either (the judges comments about that being the performance of the season--I just did not get it), and I was not wowed by this recent go at it.

 

[Robinrs]

OH, she sang, I am sorry, I had the TV on MUTE.....

Faith, you are sooo bad...

I didn't watch just listened. No, it wasn't that good. But if they butchered her she'd get more votes!

 

[Poohbear123]

Faith, you are sooo bad...

I didn't watch just listened. No, it wasn't that good. But if they butchered her she'd get more votes!

I know, why be good? GO TAYLOR SOUL PATROL RULES!!!!

 

[WDWLVR]

Taylor #2 - He looks great in this suit, this is a great song for him. The more mellow Taylor. Well a mellow start at least

 

[TIGGER'SFRIEND]

Get down Taylor

 

[escape]

Although I don't care for her version of Over the Rainbow I will have to say that it showed off her incredible voice.

Beautiful!

 

[lillygator]

wow - Taylor rocked. I thought Katharine did well with the first one but I didn't think OTR was that great....

 

[Poohbear123]

Well, he had to say something!

 

[Robinrs]

Hey they're making this a competition!

 

[lbgraves]

Again, I liked Kat's version of OTR. Why is it OK for Taylor to sing a song he has done before but not her??? Whatever...they are both sounding good tonight. I can't wait to hear their new songs!!!

 

[Robinrs]

Totally off topic but they resurrected my FAVORITE Airtran commercial, where the guy is fired over the phone! OMG I love that comml!!!

 

[MickeyMouseGal]

Levon is a great song and Taylor did a great job with it. I guess they have to give each one of them a 'victory' so that people don't whine about the judges 'fixing' the show.