American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[lillygator]

so far what I was expecting - wow....now we know Dial Idol is kind of accurate!

 

[Fan2CSkr]

Lisa and Ace arent a shocker. I dont think Katarine is either but I guess shes the one. If Lisa is voted off will that really be a shock? Was that a big pot leaf on the back of Wyclef's jacket?

 

[Nancy]

Randy was so right, they have to pick better songs

 

[damo]

Phew!!!!

 

[Nancy]

So where was the big shock? Lisa was a no brainer!

 

[Fan2CSkr]

No shock at all.

 

[lillygator]

well, I am not surprised, I think she will have a good stage career though!

 

[damo]

I guess Katharine was the big shocker.

I'm not done looking at Ace yet and Katharine should hang on for a while yet.

I must say that Lisa has an incredible amount of composure.

 

[Papa Deuce]

Personally I liked her for her infectious personality. At least for me it was.

 

[Fan2CSkr]

This is why Lisa was voted off. She didnt get a single note right.

 

[lillygator]

do you have a link to the Paula thing? Then I can go tot bed and not worry about watching the news!!

 

[ShuisFan584]

I really wasn't shocked at the bottom 3 tonight. The obvious would have been Lisa, Ace and Bucky. But as soon as it came down to Katharine and Bucky, I just knew it would be Katharine, because there had to be at least one shocker.

I'm sad to see Lisa go because I really liked her. Although when it came down to Lisa and Katharine, I was relieved to hear that it was Katharine staying. There is no way she deserved to go this early. She should definitely at least be in the top 4!

 

[lookingforward]

Katherine is great but she has so little personality when she sings. She needs to open up more, she is a great singer and quite beautiful. Lisa was soooo good during auditions but I don't think she handled the pressure well. I love Chris but he has to change his act a little bit to stay competitive. Thanks for the update because I missed the show tonight.

 

[cheerbop]

Totally agree with you on this.....I was not surprised at bottom 3..Katherine a bit, but the others?? They have been there.

So where was the big shock? Lisa was a no brainer!

 

[damo]

do you have a link to the Paula thing? Then I can go tot bed and not worry about watching the news!!

Here you go. Now go to bed.

http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/ente.../1143684607316660.xml&storylist=entertainment

 

[lillygator]

Thank you Damo!!!

 

[TnKrBeLlA012]

Lisa and Ace in the bottom three was correct. Katherine should not have been there. People are voting for favorites over talent. Ace in my view is horrible. He should be gone next week. Paris could go next. She does nothing for me. I like Bucky but he is another one that gets sympathy votes. So does Kelly. I guess next week I will have to focus on Katherine. Her and Chris are my pick for the last two.

 

[mcr5298]

I almost had a heart attack when I saw Katharine in the bottom 3!!! She did not have her best performance last night, but come on now! Kellie was not good at all last night. And Ace should not have sat down before Katharine at all! I don't care if he is cute and all the girls like him. Lisa was nice and all, and did have a good voice. But she bored me a little, so I'm not surprised to see her go.

 

[damo]

Lisa and Ace in the bottom three was correct. Katherine should not have been there. People are voting for favorites over talent. Ace in my view is horrible. He should be gone next week. Paris could go next. She does nothing for me. I like Bucky but he is another one that gets sympathy votes. So does Kelly. I guess next week I will have to focus on Katherine. Her and Chris are my pick for the last two.

Personal preference. The people who sound best to you, do not sound best to everyone.

 

[TimeforMe]

Lisa and Ace in the bottom three was correct. Katherine should not have been there. People are voting for favorites over talent. Ace in my view is horrible. He should be gone next week. Paris could go next. She does nothing for me. I like Bucky but he is another one that gets sympathy votes. So does Kelly. I guess next week I will have to focus on Katherine. Her and Chris are my pick for the last two.

I could've written this post myself--I TOTALLY agree. There is no way in heck that Katherine should've been in the bottom 3. IMO she and Chris are definitely the best by a long shot. They truly have good voices and know how to use them.