I really, really hope they will take either answer. "Special" is subjective and the degree to which each option could be called an ingredient is debatable. The journalist in me looked long and hard for an "official" answer, but since dole whip is a cult thing, there were none to be found, except for the Aloha Isle description on the WDW restaurant listing. I do know first-hand from visits, however, that there is a sign at AI that says "pineapple." Even on the Moms Panel site, some panelists call it "soft-serve ice cream" and others call it "soft-serve frozen treat." Also, some panelists call the orange flavor "orange dole whip" and others call it "orange soft-serve."
This is seriously going to drive me crazy until October

Good thing I'm going to WDW in a couple weeks and can treat myself to many dole whips before the notices come in. How ironic if my one true love, the dole whip, becomes the cause of my rejection.