It doesn't surprise me that Disney and Tim Burton are "paired". The Nightmare Before Christmas is Disney and Burton.
Charles Dodgson (aka Louis Carroll) wrote Alice in Wonderland trippy as heck and Disney's version didn't lighten it up any. If Burton's hands get on it...one can only imagine how trippy it will be! haha.
I, for one, am a huge Burton fan. I love his work. They are so unique and artistic. I just love his style.
I don't like his movies because it's "the cool new thing". I think every artist is entitled to his/her style and this is Burton's. People like it because of its style. I do think there are some people who like it because his work is so popular - but I don't think that's the majority. Tim Burton's films seem to actually be dropping on that scale of "coolness". There are subtleties in all his films that make his films more than meets the eye. That is also what I love about them. They are just so complex. I think Tim Burton has his style and his artistic "voice" and think that is why he creates his films the way he does. I give him credit for taking risks and creating some very original features. It's better than seeing the same ol' stuff pop up on the screen all the time. IMHO. Tim Burton creates his films as most painters paint, writers write, and so on. He keeps making movies the way he does because that is his style. And he is very good at it, in my opinion. All his films follow through smoothly, they all get the message across, and they even dig deeper into ideas and concepts that most people miss who don't look into it. I'm used to over-analyzing literature and artwork and so when I watch films (especially by Burton) I tend to look for the less obvious messages. His films are FULL with them.
Johnny Depp is an excellent actor in my opinion. He always has been. From Hell is amazing as are nearly all his other major roles. Just because he is building up a fan base doesn't subtract from how great of an actor he is. While I may not be "crushing" on a man who is nearly twice my age (like those 11-13 year olds you describe), I respect and appreciate him as the actor he is - because I know what his skills are and I have seen his older stuff.
It's okay to like something even though it's mainstream. To be unique doesn't always mean having to like something only because it's not popular.