4. In direct relation to this, I am going to provide 2 scenarios here that directly use the logic that many of you rebutted to me. They directly relate to my role model comment, and the fact that many of you believe that since drinking is legal, it is totally fine to partake in it around children. Here goes:
a) An elementary school teacher takes her class to Chuck E Cheese for a special field trip during school time. The teacher subscribes to the same theory as many of you: I like to drink, so I therefore should be able to drink - never mind that my priority should be my class and this isn't the most appropriate time to do so. Alcohol is legal, and so she has 2 beers during the time her class is at Chuck E Cheese.
b) I take my high school students (ages 14-19 - some underage, some not) to Toronto or New York for a field trip (museums, galleries, theatres, etc.). Each night, we eat at a different restaurant: Hard Rock Cafe, Italian restaurant or Planet Hollywood, for example. I like to drink, so again, since alcohol is legal, I have a couple of drinks each night while I am directly supervising your children. As well, for lunch, we have picnics in the park, so since I enjoy alcohol, I pull out a bottle of wine for myself to enjoy while I am eating my lunch, again, while directly supervising your children
I would love to hear your responses on these two scenarios as they use the same logic based on your rebuttals to me. In neither scenario do I become drunk, as I only have a few drinks in moderation. The point is though, as with Chuck E Cheese, anytime alcohol is served, you do have the potential for problems with drunkeness, etc., and being in the company of children, this would not be good. Anyway, the first one is hypothetical, but I absolutely know that the parent volunteers who accompanied this teacher would be calling our school boards within minutes of returning home to report this teacher, and would more than likely sue our board or demand for her resignation (similar situations have happened in my city). The second one has actually happened several times in my city: one teacher was suspended and demoted (was a department head), the other one was fired.
So, what are your reponses? Using your logic that alcohol in moderation is fine in children's establishments (elementary scenario), or, that responsible drinking is ok as we are all adults (high school situation), I should mostly see that you would be ok if I did this as a teacher/role model while caring for your children, based on your rationals and responses to me.
Tiger