A Question... Am I over-reacting here?

scottishduffy

<font color=green>I was walking around and providi
Joined
Aug 21, 2007
Messages
1,429
Alright, Mainly a vent here. Just need to get this week off my chest.

DH and I went to visit my parents this week and to see my Brother and SIL who were in town with my newly 1 yr old nephew. Now, I freely admit i don't have kids but my parents and I were more than taken aback at several things. My mother addresses the issues in one conversation with my brother, yet i feel compelled to get a general consensus about our feelings. Brother basically told us we are all being way too overprotective. Soooo... a couple incidents.

1) Baby Home alone: Nephew was napping last weekend when Bro and SIL decided to go to church. The leave nephew ALONE at the house, then call DH and I from their car to say "Just show up at the house before 5, he wakes up around then." We had not been asked to babysit, he called from the road to say the baby was alone and at that moment asked us to watch the kid. :scared1:DH and I *flipped* and got to the house ASAP. Sure, baby was napping and OK.... but seriously, leaving a 1 yr old alone? Apparently Bro also left him napping alone later in the week to run errands with SIL, at which point my Mom had a long talk with Bro.

2) Allowing baby to crawl pretty much unsupervised around a pool and in a parking lot??? Bro and SIL set Baby G down on ground to crawl everywhere. At the parking lot I was picking him up from the street to not allow him to crawl there, of course nephew got upset and both parents admonished me to let him crawl in the parking lot, because he loves tires. At the pool they also set him down to crawl while they went to the hot tub. He crawls to the pool to play with water, and picked up bottle caps from the bushes to try to eat... Only myself and my father watching out for the kid.

My family and I don't mind watching nephew, we just wish they would TELL us when he needs to be watched. Instead they would just set him down to crawl or play anywhere, then expect other's to watch him.

3) We also got really sick of them ignoring him when he cried. Baby gets grumpy or upset. "Oh, he wants Auntie Duff! Oh he wants Grampa". Ummm. nooo. I have not seen Baby for 6 months, I am a virtual stranger to him. The child was reaching out for Momma, not ME. Yet SIL and my Bro refused to pick him and deal with him.

I just got frustrated when last night they again set him down to crawl at a party and did not bother to look at him for 4 hours. We tried to bring the baby back to both parents (like when he was hungry, or cranky) only to be told what a *perfect* opportunity this was for someone else to care for the little bundle of joy. I am not about to let my nephew suffer so of course I get the joy of feeding him dinner, consoling him when mom and dad let him tip over a tree, changing him into pajamas, and rocking him to sleep at a party.


I felt very put out by all this and felt like my brother and SIL were checking out as parents. Even when Baby G got a bump on his head at the party (see above mentioned tipped over decorative tree), Mom and dad were nowhere to be found. They had LEFT the party for a few minutes. He cried, i comforted him and dealt with him. I love him, but this is not MY responsibility.

I would not mind babysitting if they had come up to me earlier and asked me to. But instead they just dropped him on the ground at the party, talked about him having enough fun crawling, then didn't see him for 4-5 hours. Did not give him dinner when asked, or comfort him when he was grumpy. I told my brother i felt very put out by all of this, and was told I did not have to feed him or watch him at the party. That if he hurt himself "he would learn a lesson". That if i hadn't fed him, someone else would notice he was hungry and feed him. If he cried, then someone would pick him up and help him. Meanwhile I try to keep nephew from tipping others trees, and destroying wine bottles. :sad2: GGrr, am i right to be angered by all this? Who the heck just does this crap? Are they THAT clueless? We tried to be direct and still they brushed the baby off.

It feels good to get that out.... Thanks for the venting session.
 
I don't have kids, but I know that is not right. I'd never leave a child alone or let them crawl all over the place!!!!!!!:scared1:
 
Honestly, I am too shocked for words right now. And, I'm getting kinda mad. That poor kid.

Oh, and you have every right to be mad. Like I said, now I'm mad just reading this.
 

I realize this is your brother, and please don't be offended, BUT:

They are either crazy and endangering this child or they simply wanted a vacation and for everyone else to watch the child. If it was the latter, maybe they were too afraid you all would say no and decided to just force the issue. If the former :scared1: not sure what to tell you.
 
ok I know I don't have kids/won't be having kids, and I Know this is family...but from what you stated it sounds like they shouldn't even have a kid...If they treat their DS like this all the time, it sounds like it would be better for the baby if CPS was called and stepped in to take baby away. Doesn't sound like they would care at all....
 
To be painfully honest... that sounds like a case for DSS. That's neglect, and that child is going to get hurt. If I were you, I would make an annonomous phone call to child welfare and have them investigated. I know it's family, but if something ever happened to that baby, could you live with yourself knowing what you've witnessed?
 
Why do people like this have children? I mean, there is a choice to prevent a pregnancy if you don't want the responsibility of being a parent. You are not being "overprotective". They are neglecting their child, and something horrible is going to happen. It's a question of when, not if. I am really concerned for this child and I really think someone needs to make a call to child protective services. It can only take a few seconds for this to become a tragedy.
 
Wow. The next time they leave the baby alone in the house and then call you, I'd call the cops and then drive over to meet them at the door. This is a disaster just waiting to happen. Did they want to have a child?
 
Leaving a infant unattended will give parents a one way ticket to "the big house".;) Letting a child crawl around a pool and/or parking lot is just asking for a drowning or accident.

You are not over reacting. I would call child protective services. You can do so anonymously.
 
ok, I have found a few words, still too mad for most of them

leaving a 1 yr old home alone is illegal and for good reason. What if something happens, no one is there to get him out of the house. What if he climbs out of his crib! What if there is an electrical short and the house catches on fire! He cannot help himself! They are his parents and need to be there to help him.

Crawling in a parking lot!! Are you serious!! What if a car whips thru there and doesn't see him. I have almost been hit in a parking lot and I'm easier to see than a 1 yr old.

ggggrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr :mad:
 
If you haven't called CPS on them then you are UNDER reacting. A BABY cannot be left alone in a house even if it's asleep.
 
To be painfully honest... that sounds like a case for DSS. That's neglect, and that child is going to get hurt. If I were you, I would make an annonomous phone call to child welfare and have them investigated. I know it's family, but if something ever happened to that baby, could you live with yourself knowing what you've witnessed?

I agree.
 
We were just amazed by it all. At home they have a regular sitter care for nephew during the week, so he is not alone. At home they hoem make all organic baby food, cloth diaper him, very natural with him. Yet, the lack of supervision as to his crawling and location was more than bothersome. My bro just checked out and SIL has severe vision issue and can't see him more than 5 feet away.

When we have seen them at home they seemed better, but on vacation to see us they just ditched the little guy! Then again, he wasn't crawling or mobile last time we saw him. They were still wearing him everywhere. Now, they let him crawl anywhere and everywhere and we were just astounded because while G's house may be baby proof, everywhere else is NOT.

We tried being direct and saying "Here, your son is fussy and wants you." or "Here, G is crawling in the bushes, you should get him". But would basically just get told that WE are family and could help the little guy.
 
To be painfully honest... that sounds like a case for DSS. That's neglect, and that child is going to get hurt. If I were you, I would make an annonomous phone call to child welfare and have them investigated. I know it's family, but if something ever happened to that baby, could you live with yourself knowing what you've witnessed?


ITA. IMO, you have an obligation to report to report this to child protective services, even if it's family. There is no circumstance under which the "parenting" you've described is loving, safe or appropriate.
 
Wow, I don't have kids but I feel really bad for the baby. I think that you should probably talk to your parents about this and the child protection series, because the baby being left alone in the house is a horrible and dangerous situation. You are not overreacting.
 
Usually when I see a post titled "am I overreacting", my first instinct is yes. Not in this case. I agree with the other posters that this may be a case for child protective services.

How did your brother respond when your mother confronted him about leaving the child alone? Did he agree to not do it again? If not, I would definitely be calling, anonymously or not! There is just too much risk and you will never forgive yourself if something happened and you didn't pursue this.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom