50's Prime Time or Fantasmic with H&V?

[Kanga1]

Which would you choose? Would like the atmosphere of Prime Time but don't know if we need the package. There are 6 in our party...me, DH, DD5, DNiece12, DBIL50-something, and DMIL78. We're going in late June on a night with one Fantasmic show.

What would you do?

 

[bornwiththeears]

On our last trip (May) we at at both Prime time & H & V - we enjoyed both! H & V is a buffet - lots of selections - and my family of four had enough to pick from. At PT we had the fried chicken (loved the mashed potatoes) and pot roast and both were good. We had a good waiter and enjoyed the atmosphere. I probably would pick Prime Time (especially if you have not eaten there before) because it is a "Disney" experience.