Yours is a reasonable suggestion however do you think the premium villas are going unused, There is going to be a lot of breakage because of this policy and those rooms will be available for CASH not points. What I thought should have been done is cancel a years worth of points and not charge a year's MF's I expect that the 50% rule will be with
DVC forever as it will increase breakage and serve as a incentive to buy more points direct from Disney for DVC'ers with a small point holding.