Most of the negative reviews that I've seen had more to do with the lack of good games than the system itself. Some people aren't wild about the 3D aspect (or the fact that kids aren't supposed to use the 3D for extended periods of time), but once you turn that off the screen looks just like the one on the DSi. Most gaming and tech sites sound pretty excited about the 3DS at this point, since lots of major games are coming out over the next few months. For most people who already have a DSi, it might not be worth buying a 3DS quite yet simply because the games aren't really there yet. But for someone who wants one of the games coming out in the next month or so, or someone who doesn't have a DS or DSi and hasn't yet enjoyed the games that were made for those systems (which will work on the 3DS), the 3DS is a good choice.