
We've done 3 Disney cruises and loved them

. We did 1 short NCL and we were not happy at all .
Like many others on this board I'd like to start planning our vacation for summer 2015. We will be celebrating DS HS graduation

and DH 50th bday

.
I've been contemplating cruising with
Royal Caribbean or Norweigian...but I'm afraid we will be dispappointed

.
Is room service included in these? Are the rooms that much smaller (I can tell we lose storing space). Are there many different "NICE" options for dinner that is included? Can we add a wine/beer package?
You're going to get dozens of response, and dozens of individual differing opinions on this.
I've cruised 10 or so times on 4 different lines (
DCL, NCL,
RCCL, CCL). Though I admittedly don't have a large enough sample to make an accurate comparison, here's how I rank the lines:
1) DCL
2) RCCL (very close second)
3) CCL (distant 3rd)
4) NCL (distant 4th)
I admit that's not necessarily fair of me, it's so dependent on the ships. For Royal we cruised on the Allure which I absolutely loved! But we've never done one of the bigger Carnival or NCL ships, only some of the smaller ones. It's possible (though unlikely I think) that we would enjoy the Carnival Breeze or Norwegian Breakaway more than the Allure. We've also only done the Magic on DCL, it's possible that after our Fantasy cruise next month RCCL becomes a distant second. It's also possible the DCL slides down.
As far as room size, if you compare category by category Carnival is really the only line that compares to DCL in room size. However, for the price you'll pay on DCL, you can likely get a much higher category on another line that will likely yield you the same (or in most cases more) room compared to DCL.
For food... I don't think any line is all that great. NCL is probably the best *IF* you do their specialty dining every night. RCCL also has a number of specialty dining options, especially on the bigger ships. All of this costs extra, but if food is important I would factor that in to the cost of the cruise. If you're ok with Applebees quality dining, and want to do the main dining room every night, I would personally steer clear of NCL. I'm also not a fan of CCL's new menu. Before 2012 I really enjoyed their menu, but the new one just doesn't sit as well.
Each line has drink and wine packages, none allow you to bring on your own beer or liquor like DCL does. Of these four lines, IMHO RCCL has the best drink package, but they each have their own nuances and sweet spots, so you should look at the differences and see what fits best for you.
Every line has room service. We typically only use room service for breakfast, and for that I think RCCL, at least on the Allure, shines the brightest. DCL is nice though, the cookies, cheese plates, etc are somewhat unique.
If I were you... I'd start another thread for this question, and also read through the numerous other threads in the past on the subject.
Lastly, I'll say we've never had a bad cruise. If you can manage your expectations and understand the differences in the cruise lines/ships, there's no reason you can't have a good time no matter what you choose.
