I did a B2B cruise first the DVC cruise and then a 3 night cruise. This was my first and second cruise with Disney. I loved both...but I'm not so sure it was worth the extra money. The positives I found as a first time cruiser, were fewer kids, people who shared a common interest (Disney lovers!), and getting to to Castaway Cay twice! I loved the gifts we got, but I've heard the gifts from previous years were better. I hate to say it, but I also felt like the guest were a bit nicer on the DVC cruise. The cons: too short to really enjoy the ship because they have soo many extra things going on, and the extra cost. I'm going on the Fantasy for a week in October next year. We have a GTY veranda cabin booked. I think it cost the same if not less then what I paid for the DVC cruise.