2012 Beach and Yacht FAQ ~ March, April and May ~Do Not Post Here-Old Thread

[BCV23]

First...

I feel like we are running around in the same circles. The way I see it is this...you (or me, or anyone who is choosing a WDW resort) can look up the most recent decor in a room. The term "outdated" is completely subjective and up to an individuals own taste. I think that if you see the decor and like it, you should go with it. Now "outdated" and "poor condition" are totally separate animals. A room can be "outdated" but be in excellent condition. A room can also be "updated" but have broken furniture, room features that don't work, thus "poor condition". Look at the pics...do you think you'll like it...if so, go for it. If you get a room in "poor condition", you ask for better accommodations. If you get a room that you feel is "outdated" , you just failed to do your research. Hoping that helps to ease your mind.

This exactly. We just stayed BC CL last month & it was one of the most updated, sparkling clean rooms I've stayed in onsite. It was gorgeous & had a very formal feel to it. However, right before that we stayed at BVC in a studio. I had read LOTS of reviews that BCV was worn down & "outdated" - and I got there & LOVED it. Yes the decor was completely opposite - it was very laid back & beach cottage looking - but nothing was worn out or broken or faded. I'd stay at either again in a heartbeat (and I plan too!)

I don't think you have anything to worry about. Don't let a few disgruntled guests spoil it .

Agree with you both.

TaraPA, that sounds horrible. Feel better soon.

Not sure I saw this answered but with the boards the way they are that may be because I missed the answer two pages ago. You are correct, we have no cabanas, we have no cabanas today.

Dee, sounds like a wonderful vacation. Enjoy.

 

[mmmears]

I've been reading this thread lately and I thought I'd just jump in and say "hi" and thanks for all the great, updated information. I recently booked a stay at the YC CL and it's been a while since we have stayed there.

 

[RobinHoodGirl]

On a wee bit of a off-topic note (but still related to my trip)...

My DBF has been looking for a job so talk to vacation has been null due to the price. Yes, we are aware that this trip will cost a bit of cash but it's to celebrate my 30th birthday, his first WDW vacation, and our first vacation together so we're willing to spend some money (and due to some VERY unfortunate events in my life this trip will not make much a dent into my personal savings)

He got news yesterday that he'll have an interview at a place he'd be PERFECT for It's in his field, close to what he was doing before he moved, and not to far from where he lives. He goes in on Thursday and I'm trying not to put all my eggs in one basket but it'd do a lot for him to get this. Then we can start both getting excited about November; or at least I can get excited and he won't be worry about the cost.

He's had a hard time since moving cross country 7 months ago so we can really use this good news.

Who knows maybe this till be will celebrate my 30th birthday, his first WDW vacation, our first vacation together, and him finding a good job in his field!

Back to your regular scheduled WDW planning/reporting

 

[pas130]

Ahhhh yes...I need some good humor today - I now have dry socket in 2 incisions from my wisdom teeth removal last week. Ugh. Marlton Mom come save the day LOL!

I sure wish I was recuperating on a balcony at BC right about now!

Feel better Tara


Just wanted to pop in and say hello to pixarmom glad you had a great trip!!!

 

[Raenstoirm]

One thing I didnt notice in all the write ups....is there a pin trading book/board/thing anywhere? WL (our normal resort) has a pin cart with a trading book open all day. Contemporary has a board it shares with a few other resorts (so the CMs told me), so it only appears every few days and in short intervals. I think Poly might have a permanent board (never stayed there, but it always seems to be out when we visit). Does BC or YC have something?
I get ready faster than my husband, so I always head to the pin book to do a trade while waiting for him in the morning.

Ahhhh yes...I need some good humor today - I now have dry socket in 2 incisions from my wisdom teeth removal last week. Ugh.

I sure wish I was recuperating on a balcony at BC right about now!

I feel ya! I chipped a pre-molar two weeks ago. It wasnt so bad that a root canal had to be done, but they did have to shave it down for a crown. I have never had a "live" tooth crowned before. i was in pain for a week! I got the crown put on today and the Novocain is wearing off I can already feel the pain coming back. That little tooth does not like to get messed with! Good thing is, the pain cant be worse than the original drilling, so I will be feeling fine by our trip next week!

Who knows maybe this till be will celebrate my 30th birthday, his first WDW vacation, our first vacation together, and him finding a good job in his field!

That would be great. I hope he gets it!

 

[ClareH37]

I've switched from my BC standard room to YC CL for my upcoming December trip.

I last stayed at the YC in 2006 and I'm really looking forward to returning

I don't really make use of the food offerings, apart from breakfast and tea/coffee and perhaps some crudités before heading out for my evening meal, but do like to relax in the cl lounge during 'quieter' times - I'd appreciate some feedback on the lounge please as from what I remember it's quite small (?), ie how is breakfast in terms of table availability?

I'm going the first week of December

 

[pixarmom]

thanks Pixarmom. I LOVE YC rooms. I found them so clean and fresh and new looking which leads me to my next question. Per the allearsnet SEVERAL people stated the BC rooms were outdated. Reviews were rom 2010 and 2011 so it was after the last rehab. Thoughts on it? Are BC rooms tired as compared to YC> thanks!

I think BC, YC and BWI rooms are all in excellent condition. I think the whole white down comforter thing helps to keep them looking fresh and new - can't hide dirt there! Here are comparison photos all in a row - BWI and BC from August 2011 and YC from last week:

My YC photo is much better than the other two because I had to keep four people waiting behind me until I took the picture at BWI and BC (the BC photo is of one of the bedrooms in the 2-bedroom suite, but it's exactly the same as a regular room.) It was just two of us at YC, and I was able to keep our youngest still for a moment while I took the YC photo. And the windows and sliding glass door in that particular YC room provided better lighting for the photo. But I absolutely think BC rooms are in great condition.

 

[scottmel]

I've switched from my BC standard room to YC CL for my upcoming December trip.

I last stayed at the YC in 2006 and I'm really looking forward to returning

I don't really make use of the food offerings, apart from breakfast and tea/coffee and perhaps some crudités before heading out for my evening meal, but do like to relax in the cl lounge during 'quieter' times - I'd appreciate some feedback on the lounge please as from what I remember it's quite small (?), ie how is breakfast in terms of table availability?

I'm going the first week of December

Hey Clare! Oh no lounge isn't small I don't think at all. BWI had a better layout of tables in my opinion, seating seemed better but YC lounge not small to me at all. We go at resort capacity in June and NEVER had a problem with a table at 8 am etc...

 

[TaraPA]

One thing I didnt notice in all the write ups....is there a pin trading book/board/thing anywhere? WL (our normal resort) has a pin cart with a trading book open all day. Contemporary has a board it shares with a few other resorts (so the CMs told me), so it only appears every few days and in short intervals. I think Poly might have a permanent board (never stayed there, but it always seems to be out when we visit). Does BC or YC have something?
I get ready faster than my husband, so I always head to the pin book to do a trade while waiting for him in the morning.



I feel ya! I chipped a pre-molar two weeks ago. It wasnt so bad that a root canal had to be done, but they did have to shave it down for a crown. I have never had a "live" tooth crowned before. i was in pain for a week! I got the crown put on today and the Novocain is wearing off I can already feel the pain coming back. That little tooth does not like to get messed with! Good thing is, the pain cant be worse than the original drilling, so I will be feeling fine by our trip next week!



That would be great. I hope he gets it!

Thanks for the well wishes - and thank to everyone for sending good thoughts my way. I have a pharmacist friend that is dropping off some clove oil shortly - that's what they put in dry sockets to numb them!

YES BC has a pin book - it's at the Concierge Desk. I had no idea until my boys were pin trading with Teena & she walked us over to show us. The Concierge staff was extremely knowledgeable about pins & pin trading & we spent a good deal of time there with them.

 

[mmmears]

I also tried to pm Marlton Mom - but it won't go through.

I urge anyone who enjoyed their BC CL stay to post a review on All Ears.

After my "good BC CL" review following BWIFAN's horrible reivew and wierd, yet someone familiar, poster "Nigel Channing" posted a scathing review of BC CL - especially the CL CM's.

But worse of all - he posted that the BC Lobby smelled - HORRIBLE!!!!

Someone really seems like they have it out for BC CL. Who could it be????

Hmmm... We stayed at the BC CL summer of 2010 and I can't find anything negative about the entire stay. The CMs on the 5th floor were so nice and helpful, especially when my DD was really sick. They cancelled our activity for the day and made sure we got a refund since we really couldn't go. Then they allowed us to stay in the room until our next room was ready (switching resorts on a long trip). I don't know what we would have done without their help.

 

[pumpkinfish]

Hi pumpkinfish! GV CL rooms are on the 5th floor (same as the lounge!)

Thank you so much!
Does anyone know if BC CL send an automatic response email when you email IPO? I sent an email to them yesterday and didn't get anything in response.

 

[pixarmom]

Do the buses that stop at the Beach Club also stop at other resorts before proceeding to their destination.

We've stayed at BC during different times of year, and have found that generally, the bus usually goes direct to MK or AK around rope drop time, but stops at BWI during slower times of day. On the way back to BC from MK or AK, the bus usually stops at Swan/Dolphin and YC before dropping off at BC.

WELL DONE. Very positive

I agree with HockeyMom! Very well done and very positive, Robyn!

I recently booked our family of four for a YC CL trip for December 1-8, 2012! This is only our second trip to Disney...first was in 2005, when DH, DS#1 and I stayed at the Sugarloaf (DS#2 tagged along in utero ). I considered another Sugarloaf stay this go round, but I thought we should try something new, and I feel like the boys and their dad will enjoy the nautical theme of YC. (As will I, the Naval commander's daughter )

Welcome, Steph!!! I'd love to hear your thoughts regarding YC vs Sugarloaf when you return! We're doing a monster split stay next year, and GF Sugarloaf is on the list. It's a new resort for us, so I'm excited to learn all I can.

Let us know if you have any questions!

THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!! For the great pictures and info. Still haven't gotten to your comparison review yet. That's next.

Hi Dee! Happy Vacationing!!! I was just reviewing my not-yet-posted photos and thinking of you. Remember when you asked for photos of "rocking chairs at YC?" You'll laugh when you see how many photos of YC rocking chairs I took - I didn't realize how many there are until I accepted this mission! Hope you're having a wonderful time at Atlantis!!

Pixarmom - You are my twin sister!!!
Great review!!!!

BC will always be my favorite but I wouldn't hesitate to stay at YC ever.

They are so similar with just a few differences.

The main thing that makes us pick BC over YC is the close proximity to BC Marketplace. Even when we stay CL we still like to be able to run down to the Marketplace. One of my dd's is obsessed with the turkey and mozzarella sandwich at BC Marketplace!

So glad that you enjoyed YC so much.

Thanks, Robyn! Just when I feel like I'm alone in my love of the BC Marketplace, I learn that I am not! We should start a BC Marketplace fan club - we love it there. It's the perfect mix of groceries, merchandise, fun snacks (we recently discovered that Goofy Candy Co sour gummy characters are the best packaged candy snack ever!) and CS food.

We stayed BC in November (after a June YC stay). Both rooms were very nice, neither tired nor dated. No worries!

Thanks Pixarmom for the great comparison review!!

I know so many people ask, whats the difference? or will I like one better than the other? We definitely have a first choice, but certainly don't think less of the other if our first choice is unavailable. I like that they are both similar, but yet have their own individual flavor, if you will.

Completely agree with Cinderumbrella!

Ahhhh yes...I need some good humor today - I now have dry socket in 2 incisions from my wisdom teeth removal last week. Ugh. Marlton Mom come save the day LOL!

I sure wish I was recuperating on a balcony at BC right about now!

Feel better, Tara! Hang in there!

Feel better Tara


Just wanted to pop in and say hello to pixarmom glad you had a great trip!!!

Hi Pas! So good to hear from you! I'm hopping over to the RC thread as soon as I catch up on everything!

 

[BCV23]

Tara, glad relief is on the way.

I've switched from my BC standard room to YC CL for my upcoming December trip.

I last stayed at the YC in 2006 and I'm really looking forward to returning

I don't really make use of the food offerings, apart from breakfast and tea/coffee and perhaps some crudités before heading out for my evening meal, but do like to relax in the cl lounge during 'quieter' times - I'd appreciate some feedback on the lounge please as from what I remember it's quite small (?), ie how is breakfast in terms of table availability?

I'm going the first week of December

We've only had one short wonderful YC club stay the first week of Dec a couple years ago. While the lounge is smaller than the others we've stayed (Polynesian, GF both levels and AKL), we found a table without any problem for breakfast. We were there for an unusually rainy weekend so I would guess the lounge was more crowded than usual and it was still not a problem. After breakfast, it was not crowded at all Very peaceful. Enjoy!

 

[BCV23]

mmmears, nice to see you.

 

[pixarmom]

Thank you so much!
Does anyone know if BC CL send an automatic response email when you email IPO? I sent an email to them yesterday and didn't get anything in response.

Sure! When we stayed at BWI and BC CLs last August, we received the auto response every time I sent a message, but I'm not sure if things have changed since then.

 

[Pinkgirl]

pixarmom - your photos are brill. Thank you so much for sharing.

Love the sliding doors in your room. I've never noticed them before, do all rooms have them or just a select few?

We are getting married at the Yacht Club Gazebo in August so I will be watching for more pictures of those cranes

 

[vyrg]

Wedding Gazebo view is super quiet and soooo pretty. you can state in your request "Wedding Gazebo View - upper floor". i think the higher up you are the better the view and you can sometimes get a sideways look at the lagoon too.

thank you very much

 

[Cinderumbrella]

I've switched from my BC standard room to YC CL for my upcoming December trip.

I last stayed at the YC in 2006 and I'm really looking forward to returning

I don't really make use of the food offerings, apart from breakfast and tea/coffee and perhaps some crudités before heading out for my evening meal, but do like to relax in the cl lounge during 'quieter' times - I'd appreciate some feedback on the lounge please as from what I remember it's quite small (?), ie how is breakfast in terms of table availability?

I'm going the first week of December

It really depends on the day, the time you go in etc. No real rhyme or reason as to when its full and when its not. But generally, it's busiest between 7:30am to 9am, in our experience.

However, our room last year was 2 away from the lounge, with a good sized balcony overlooking the gazebo. We would fill our plates and go back to the room to eat breakfast on our balcony most days, table availability or not.

 

[pixarmom]

pixarmom - your photos are brill. Thank you so much for sharing.

Love the sliding doors in your room. I've never noticed them before, do all rooms have them or just a select few?

We are getting married at the Yacht Club Gazebo in August so I will be watching for more pictures of those cranes

Thank you! I was really in love with those sliding glass doors, so I was paying attention to the doors and windows at both YC and BC from the outside. Maybe a YC expert can comment on this, but it seemed to me that most of the YC rooms had those sliding glass doors. And I was able to see a few sliding glass doors at BC, although our rooms at BC have always had the single door that opens in. Does anyone know or have notes on this?

Congratulations on your wedding! August is far enough away that I would hope they would be finished by then - it just looked like they were painting from what I could see.

 

[Cinderumbrella]

Thank you! I was really in love with those sliding glass doors, so I was paying attention to the doors and windows at both YC and BC from the outside. Maybe a YC expert can comment on this, but it seemed to me that most of the YC rooms had those sliding glass doors. And I was able to see a few sliding glass doors at BC, although our rooms at BC have always had the single door that opens in. Does anyone know or have notes on this?

Congratulations on your wedding! August is far enough away that I would hope they would be finished by then - it just looked like they were painting from what I could see.

I just looked at my pics and we definitely had a door in our BC CL room but I can't quite tell from the YC CL pics. I kind of remember sliders, but not 100% sure