Of all the "extras" the thing that temps me the most is the pirates and pals cruise. It looks so cool, but I think my kids might still be a bit young for this. It's the one thing I keep thinking *maybe* i'll squeeze it in if my husband agrees since we are no doing a desert party or a party night. But we booked so many character meals (above our table service allotment on the Dining Plan) so there is a part of me that sees that as the "extra. I don't know, they'll be 3 and 5 and I'm thinking the value they get out of the character meals will probably be higher that the pirates cruise.
I was thinking the pirates and pals cruise might work on our first night there or our last night there, but it is quite pricey and we can view the fireworks on our first night from the contemporary (we're having dinner at Chef Mickey's). Or maybe just save it as a must do activity on our NEXT trip to Disney