Have done both of these. Really love 1900PF breakfast and have been for xmas day lat breakfast for the past 3 years. I think the food quality and choices are the best here. Love the omelette station and this year tried yummy lobster eggs benedict. Characters are Mad Hatter, Alice, tigger, Pooh who circulate and Mary Poppins who usually is in the waiting area(although she did circulate last xmas). LiLo and Stitch are great at the Ohana breakfast. Goofy was also there and I think Mickey(or Minnie)..can't quite remember. They had a parade to Lilo and stitch songs for the kids with "instruments" around the restaurant..very cute, but our DS was 15 and didn't participate. Food is family style not buffet. Platter had eggs, mickey wafles, bacon, potatoes, basket of breads/pastries and they replenish what ever you want more of and the wait staff was very attentive. Coffee and juices also included. I like not having to get up for buffet, but it does limit your choices-although some folks next to us asked for toast and it was no problem. I enjoyed both, but keep returning to 1900PF.
Connears