Did you ask to speak with a MS Supervisor? If not, call back and request a Supervisor as they have to connect you with the duty Supervisor if requested. Explain your situation that nothing is available for that week and it's the second highest point requirment season of the year. Ask what you're options are for staying put and state your concerns and if nothing is offered, advise of the many resolutions you are aware of from all of the data points provided on the forums. If there is something reasonable that will make you happy then let them know that. From everything I've seen they will do their best to achieve your satisfaction in a way that is fair to both you and them. We are staying Thanksgiving week with two reservations and are staying put at the lodge as we weren't interested in moving. I spoke with them regarding these reservations and two February 2016 reservations as well.
Thanks! Disney's inconsistency on these matters drives me crazy. I dislike being told that it really is minimal and not a big deal when I know it must be because they are proactively moving people with reservations both before and after ours - just not our week because it is booked. Disney doesn't make moves like that unless they know it is going to be an inconvenience. It is frustrating. They should have a standard way of dealing with these situations instead of some kind of haphazard way that feels like playing the lottery.