For our first house, I had the opposite problem. I could see us living in every house we looked at, fixer-upper or not. There was only ONE house where we walked through and I thought to myself, there is NO WAY I would ever live here.
That's the house we bought

Because it was move-in ready. We paid way too much and the house was way too small. But it was what DH wanted, and we were in our early 20's and I had no idea how to do much more than hang curtains and he knew he would be the one fixing things when they broke.
The 2nd house, we built in a new sub in the country, honestly, before we were really ready for the commitment of a house more than twice the size and almost an acre lot. I would never do that again, either, unless I had a $30,000 contingency fund. We just figured we would do things a little bit at a time instead. Big Mistake! It took us forever to do the landscaping to our liking, and pour a patio, and we were nickel and dimed for everything down to the towel bars in the bathroom. Nothing was "pre-done"
Our 3rd house was (is) an updated 1950's Cape Cod in an established neighborhood. It was really cool because everything was done - the paper towel holder was installed on the door of the cabinet, the rack/shelf was above the dryer, the cable connections were already in place, the retaining wall was already around the flower beds. It was really kind of nice to just move in and have all of that done. But it is a 1950's Cape Cod, so the kitchen is tiny and the dining room table is in the same room as the living room, and since it's not really an "open concept" great room, it looks ridiculous.
What we looked for in each house changed depending on where we were in life at the time:
House #1 - It was just the two of us, kids were a long way off. We wanted move-in ready and low maintenance. New furnace, hot water heater, and roof.
House #2: We had a 2-year old and were looking to have more kids. We wanted bigger size, new, good yard, and safe area
House #3: 3 school-aged kids, bad economy forcing a move to a new state. We looked at school districts first, housing second. We took what we could get. It's not the house I would have picked, but it IS in one of the top school districts in our state and the house was one of the only ones for sale in our price range that was move-in ready, so we jumped on it.
House #4 - TBD....we are moving again in a few months. We are researching school districts as I speak. Again, with school-aged kids, we will pick district over house. Like now, we will make do with the house so the kids can go to school in top-rated schools. Once all of the kids are in college and beyond, DH and I plan to move into a condo. When that time comes, it will be about value for the money first, decent area a close second. We won't be worrying about school districts at that point.