Your Thoughts: Cape May Cafe Dinner

TheBacklot

Mouseketeer
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
308
My friend wants to eat dinner here. I've only had their breakfast. The menu looks diverse enough but I can't really find many photos in the photo threads here of this location.

What's your opinion on the food and the location? Thanks in advance!
 
We have been many times and have always enjoyed it - there are tons of options from ribs to chicken, carved beef and seafood, lots of carb items, veggies, salads, soups and desserts. Have reservations for next month, cant wait for the all you can eat steamers and crab legs
 
We have eaten there three times and it has been a disappointment every time. Never say never but I think we are done with the dinner buffet. We find the seafood quality is extremely poor. The other foods are boring, tasteless and not worth the calories, especially the desserts.

BUT, that said, you will find varying reviews for every Disney restaurant and I am a proponent of trying it for yourself. I hope you do enjoy it, if you decide to try it, :)
 
My friend wants to eat dinner here. I've only had their breakfast. The menu looks diverse enough but I can't really find many photos in the photo threads here of this location.

What's your opinion on the food and the location? Thanks in advance!

Love, love it - have been going there many years and have yet to have a bad experience. Everything is fresh and tasty. The crab legs are hot and delicious.

No matter what reviews you get (and there will be those that don't like it, like any other restaurant on property) you must try it for yourself. Only then will you really know whether it's a keeper!! :)

It's one of our favorite 'must do' places to dine - sometimes twice in a 10 day trip! :thumbsup2
 

Another vote for LOVE IT!!! Had dinner here in December and the entire family enjoyed it so much.
 
I really enjoyed it the time I had dinner there, and I booked it for my group this trip.
 
We are among the nay-sayers....bland food, too many people, and table and area was very dirty due to diners before us. BUT, totally agree that you should try everything. Some will like some places, some not. Tastes and timing make a difference and certainly many love it! Give it a shot!
 
Love it. We go every year, and it hasn't disappointed us yet.
 
There are lots and lots of pictures on the current Disney food picture thread.
It looks really good
 
This is the only ADR on our lineup for November that I am not too excited about because of the reviews. But my Sister and her DH ate there on their Disneymoon last November and they loved it there. They wanted to go again so we booked it. I have only been there for breakfast, so dinner is new to me. I am excited to take the boat over from Epcot and try it out! I hope its as good as some of you say it is! :thumbsup2
 
We ate there in May 2013 on our last trip. It was our only TS of the trip. I'm not a big seafood fan, but there was enough variety and I thought the food was good too.
 
Another vote for Cape May. Absolutely love this place. Probably my favorite buffet on property (Boma second).

I went earlier this month and gorged on clams and crab legs. It was fantastic!
 
I can't get excited about any of the buffets, Cape May included. It wasn't bad; which is about as good as any of these can realistically rated, IMO. You could certainly do worse. Just keep your expectations in check.
 
We are among the nay-sayers....bland food, too many people, and table and area was very dirty due to diners before us. BUT, totally agree that you should try everything. Some will like some places, some not. Tastes and timing make a difference and certainly many love it! Give it a shot!

Ditto! We are not fans, but sometimes you just have to try things for yourself and make your own decision.

Good luck!
 
Wow thank you for sharing! The food looks great! and the desserts look amazing! I am getting more excited for it now lol. :thumbsup2

Awesome pics!

We love Cape May Dinner Buffet and it's must for us every trip. We stuff ourselves on crab legs and other yummy seafood items. There is a great variety of items and plenty for us all to eat.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom