Please don't pass up a Disney restaurant because of a review or two. You'd never eat anywhere there. We really enjoyed our meal at the Yachtman Steakhouse. The garlic spread is not to be missed. The service was fantastic. Foodies tend to dis it but for us meat and potatoes people, it was great.
On the other hand, I did listen to all the wonderful reviews of the California Grill and we weren't all that impressed with it. You have to form your own opinions.