Yachtsman or Boathouse for Best Steak

[Royal Consort]

We have eaten at both to be honest although I can't really recall what the food at the Boathouse was like during our last trip. I've had one fantastic experience at Yachtsman and one where the cut of meat was really lacking. I've considered Shula's but since I'm at Disney I feel I should do something unique and I don't like the sports ambiance of Shula's. Between the Boathouse and Yachtsman - which does the better steaks in your opinion?

 

[skatalite]

Between the two, Yachtsman, hands down.

But can I suggest the wagyu at Flying Fish? Tender and tasty.

And, for what it's worth, my wife got over the very light sports ambiance of Shula's rather quickly. She found the setting rather intimate, even if they do bring the cut menu out on a football

 

[Uncleromulus]

Shulas is hardly sports themed--at least not like ESPN etc. Rather it is mostly pictures on the wall of some teams and players. Mostly it is a quiet and romantic place to dine--and the STEAK is excellent!!!

Problem with the filet at FF--it's the ONLY steak they have.

Had steak at both Boathouse and YSH--for me a toss up, but since there is no bar at YSH where you can get a full meal, we do Boathouse.

 

[OKW Lover]

Between Boathouse and YSH there is no question in our mind that YSH has the better steak.

Between YSH and Shulas, YSH still acquits itself really well.

However, far above all the above choices sits Bull & Bear at the Waldorf Astoria.