WWYD Magic or Wonder?

[MUN]

I have 2 days off in March during Spring Break where I have the option of going on the re-imagined Wonder for 3 nights out of PC or a 4 night out of Miami on the Magic.

I have been on the Dream twice, but haven't tried the classic ships yet. I am intrigued on going on a recent reno of the Wonder and their new Tiana restaurant but Magic would give me an extra day and be closer to home(Miami)

Any suggestions?

Neither. 3 day and 4 day cruises are just too short.

 

[Club Disney Chandler]

I put a 3 day hold on the magic, I want to sleep on it....and see what my options are at work to see if I can squeeze another day off..and do the 5 day Magic. Thanks for all the recommendations!

I would do the 4 or 5 day Magic over the Wonder. We just booked the 8 day out of New York for October 2017. We did the Wonder last year and like the Dream class ships better than the Wonder but still haven't met a ship we haven't enjoyed yet.

 

[Laundress]

Very tuff decision. We are partial to the wonder. Seeing it reimagined would be tempting especially if the ship were my destination and not the ports.

 

[Love2Cruz]

Neither. 3 day and 4 day cruises are just too short.

I just got back from a 3 Day on the Dream and I swore to myself that my next DCL will not be shorter than the 7 day....but here I am contemplating another short cruise...(I do longer cruises on other lines so I still get my cruise fix)

I'm still not sure I'm going to book the 4 day, I might just do a WDW resort stay instead. I'm waiting for Disney to announce their FL resident discount for Spring...I'm hoping they'll be released soon so I can decide.

 

[Rabb it]

Magic Magic Magic!

 

[Disnut4925]

Yes Magic! One more night is much better!

 

[AquaDame]

Sounds like you picked Magic, but I just gotta pipe up that I would do the same and I love the wonder... 3 nights is not enough!

 

[RedSox68]

If I had to choose, I'd pick the Magic over the Wonder. Always felt that she was a little classier. And being the first ever Disney ship, it's kind of a right of passage LOL

 

[Love2Cruz]

Thanks everyone for all your opinions, I decided to let the hold expire and not re-book. After this months experience on the Dream, I decided to wait till I can do a 7 night cruise on the Fantasy before booking another short cruise. They have such a busy schedule of events on DCL that it's impossible to truly enjoy it on the shorter cruises and I always felt rushed to try to make the next thing...but still never got around to doing all that I wanted to do.

But don't feel sorry for me just yet, I have lots of cruises booked in the meantime on other lines that won't break my piggy bank. Hopefully 2019 will the year I can do DCL Fantasy.

 

[redsonja76]

I always prefer the Magic because it's the first ship I sailed on and I love her. Plus, it's closer to your home, you get an extra day, and SCHWARMAS.

 

[Ofinn]

Thanks everyone for all your opinions, I decided to let the hold expire and not re-book. After this months experience on the Dream, I decided to wait till I can do a 7 night cruise on the Fantasy before booking another short cruise. They have such a busy schedule of events on DCL that it's impossible to truly enjoy it on the shorter cruises and I always felt rushed to try to make the next thing...but still never got around to doing all that I wanted to do.

But don't feel sorry for me just yet, I have lots of cruises booked in the meantime on other lines that won't break my piggy bank. Hopefully 2019 will the year I can do DCL Fantasy.

I cant keep up with all the cruises you have booked. I have a lot booked too ...in my head and it changes daily.
If it means anything we prefer the Wonder, but if itinerarys not important the Fantasy would be the best choice.

 

[Love2Cruz]

I cant keep up with all the cruises you have booked. I have a lot booked too ...in my head and it changes daily.
If it means anything we prefer the Wonder, but if itinerarys not important the Fantasy would be the best choice.

I've changed a few things around....but I'm fairly certain these are my cruises for the rest of this year, and 2017...In 2018 I will be adding one more MSC cruise but those itineraries aren't out yet..so not booked yet....but planning on their new Seaside ship out of Miami.