We did both -- dinner at Chef's on 9/19 and Lunch at Le Cellier 9/20.
Food at Chef's was good -- DH had the duck, I had the tenderloin. Our waiter was awful. He was an older gentleman -- surly, dismissive, barely spoke to us, slow...and very attentive to the table next to us. They were clearly repeat customers and he stood and chatted with them while we waited for our check. And waited...and waited. Then he took our KTTW, and left...and we waited. And waited. And waited. Until the manager came by our table and asked if everything was ok and we said, "NO! Our waiter disappeared with our card, we just got here, we're exhausted from our long flight, and we want to go back to our hotel now." The manager offered to buy us a drink, but we declined, said we really just wanted to get back to our hotel to rest. Finally, the waiter appeared with a mumbled apology that he was having problems with the computer. Based on that service, I can't see that we will make another ADR at Chef's. The food was good, but not THAT good.
Lunch at Le Cellier was fabulous. Our waiter was great, very knowledgeable about the food, and friendly, attentive without being obtrusive, which is great service. We ordered a cup of the cheddar cheese soup to taste -- it was just right for dipping our bread, sort of like a cheese fondue. It was delicious but very, very rich -- I can't imagine eating a whole bowl of it. The party at the table next to us was on the deluxe plan and the woman who ordered the soup couldn't finish it (she told us yes, the deluxe was just WAY too much food). Our steaks were...probably the best steaks we have ever eaten. Anywhere. We both got the mushroom filet (his medium rare, mine medium, we got them just as we ordered). I had the risotto, he had the cream cheese mashed potatoes, both were wonderful. I got the maple creme brulee, which was great and very "Canadian", but he got the cherry sorbet which was incredible...glad he shared with me
