WWY have done - dd9 came home with a 75 on her social studies

There are some other questions to ask:

Is this material she had learned before and forgot? Does she take notes in this class? Was it covered in some other worksheet?

A study guide is used to help focus students before a large assessment, because a large unit test can't go over every piece of material. So while not study guide can be a problem, the student should have already learned all the information on the test.

So that leads the question of whether the assessment was valid. If it was assessing knowledge students didn't learn, it's not a valid assessment. If the question is something they should have been able to answer, how did the students learn about it?

Also, were there only 4 questions on on the test?
 
If it was the last test of the quarter and the teacher had always prepared a study guide for all tests, then I would have expected my child to ask the teacher her/himself for it when they knew they didn't have it. I would use this test as a teaching moment for my child that they need to be more responsible for things like this.
 
Thanks for the replies. I felt bad for chastising her, before learning about the study guide. I have an awesome relationship with this teacher. Some teachers will send work home, some will wait until the child comes back to school. My dd averages 2 sick days a year, and I only kept her home because she had a 2 week cold, and couldn't stop coughing that day. I do have older kids, who are on their own - we're taking them out 2 days next week, and they were responsible for telling their teachers. In 4th grade, they don't take notes - they study from study guides (it's all coming back to me - it's been 3 years since I had a fourth grader). Here is the test:

sstest.jpg

sstest2.jpg
 
If it was the last test of the quarter and the teacher had always prepared a study guide for all tests, then I would have expected my child to ask the teacher her/himself for it when they knew they didn't have it. I would use this test as a teaching moment for my child that they need to be more responsible for things like this.

But this is the first marking period - honestly, I don't know how many tests they've had, because I've never had to sign one before. Dd is bright, but I don't know if she would've noticed a pattern of test/study guides this early on. She's a quiet, go with the flow, stay under the radar kid.
 
Why is it that when a kid forgets something that they are irresponsible. Yet when a teacher forgets something, well then it was ok, (not saying you said this) You can't tie donw a teacher and force them to give you something, the work was requested, what is kid supposed to do, scream and yell until she gets it.
What I find most interesting on this thread is that some posters think the child is STILL at fault for not receiving the study guide :confused3. I support teachers ... they have a tough and important job ... but they are not infallible.
 
What I find most interesting on this thread is that some posters think the child is STILL at fault for not receiving the study guide :confused3. I support teachers ... they have a tough and important job ... but they are not infallible.

If this family has had 2 other kids with this teacher, the mom volunteers with the class, the child has had other tests and they have ALL gotten study guides, wouldn't it occur to you to ask for one if you didn't get one.

OP, that test is right out of her book. Did she read or study from the book before the test?
 
But this is the first marking period - honestly, I don't know how many tests they've had, because I've never had to sign one before. Dd is bright, but I don't know if she would've noticed a pattern of test/study guides this early on. She's a quiet, go with the flow, stay under the radar kid.

I guess thats where we are different, I know about every test beforehand, at least a week. My kids have planners, my youngest's teacher sends a newsletter home everyweek with the test dates on them. I can't imagine not knowing about tests, or not knowing how the classroom is run so I can help my child be prepared and "notice the patterns". The end of the first marking period is 2 months after the beginning of the year, I would definitely expect my kids to know how things work by then.
 
Seriously, this is one test in 4th grade. You are so upset about it you scanned the test for us to see. I don't get it.

She got the answers wrong. As long as she knows the right ones that is a bigger issue than passing a test. :confused3

Study guides only help them study. She probably learned this in class (a few different times). A study guide is helpful, but so is paying attention, taking notes, and doing the work in class.

I would not say anything to the teacher. I would not possibly damage my relationship with a good teacher by implying that my daughter got a 75 because she didn't give her a study guide.

I would tell my daughter that if she doesn't get a study guide to ask for one. Lesson learned.
 
was that whole section she had problems with just on the study guide, and not in the book/classes? DH says if he gave a test on material a student was never given to study, he'd go back and re-grade the test leaving out that section that the student could not possibly have learned. If it's a 25 question test, and 5 questions were on material ONLY learned from a study guide a student mistakenly never got, he'd grade THEIR test out of 20.

I would, however, have DD approach the teacher about it. Even my 2nd grader is made to deal directly with her own teacher, her dance teacher, etc. I role-play a touch to practice what she will say, but I make her do it.

My kids don't generally lie about school (the younger 2, specifically, lol). But I'd feel a fool if I approached a teacher on their behalf and it happened to be the first time they DID lie, lol.

So my advice (if that NJ section is what was info dd truly never had a moment's access to) is to practice with dd how to approach her teacher, and let her do it. Perhaps she can ask the teacher where that information came from, since she studied but never came across that information. If the teacher answers that it was in the study guide, she can ask when that was given out and mention that it wasn't in her stuff she got post-absence. She can even ask the teacher if she can get the study guide now, and re-take that portion of the test (or even a different version of it) the next day.

But being the mean mom that i am, I'd definitely have the KID approach the teacher about it. Good practice to learn to advocate for oneself, and perhaps she will be careful to doublecheck what all she missed next absence, if she doesn't like what can go wrong. Also, an important first step is to check her book carefully, and make sure that stuff wasn't in the book. That test LOOKS like the book publisher's test, completely unaltered by the teacher. But it could have been a similar unit from a different book...so check before embarassing yourself. If you DO find that section in her book, show dd so she knows she really DID just make some mistakes on her test.

Good luck to her! The rest of her test, it looks like she did great!
 
What I find most interesting on this thread is that some posters think the child is STILL at fault for not receiving the study guide :confused3. I support teachers ... they have a tough and important job ... but they are not infallible.

I don't think the OP's dd is totally at fault, the teacher should have put a study guide in the pile of make-up work she had. However, if the teacher has given out study guides for other tests, I would expect the student to let the teacher know she didn't get one, especially if she knew that a test was coming up. I don't think thats too much to ask, to me part of a child's education is learning to be a responsible independent student. In our school, 4th grade is really where teachers start to empasize that since the are getting so close to middle school.
 
How could your dd possibly have known the teacher would have left something out?

I think that the OP said that she knew there should have been a study guide because two of her other children had taken the class and had gotten them. If that is the case, I probably would have asked the teacher why my child didn't get a study guide. Or, better yet, your daughter could have asked the teacher for a study guide when she realized she wasn't given one.

I do feel bad for your daughter, especially since she usually gets all A's. However, I wouldn't give it another thought. I have a senior in college and a senior in high school who is now applying to colleges, and any grade they received in 4th grade has never mattered. The only thing that really matters is your GPA in high school.
 
If this family has had 2 other kids with this teacher, the mom volunteers with the class, the child has had other tests and they have ALL gotten study guides, wouldn't it occur to you to ask for one if you didn't get one.

OP, that test is right out of her book. Did she read or study from the book before the test?

Yes, I had 2 other students in this class. I'm lucky - my kids are pretty on the ball, I believe kids need to be responsible for their schoolwork, so no, I don't monitor when they have quizzes and tests, and I don't go over their homework. I recall this particular study guide, because sometimes my older kids would ask me to quiz them. I have never volunteered in this class - our school doesn't have volunteers. The class moms bring in stuff for parties, and collect money for class gifts. She did read from the book - there was a question on the test that even I couldn't find in the chapter.

The study guide IS the test. I will have to get over seeing a B on a fourth grade report card. The only grades that really count in elementary school are in the 6th grade, because if you don't get an A, you don't get into vector in middle school, and then you don't get into honors in high school. I know that grades aren't the most important thing in the world, but when you have 5 kids you need to get through college, they're somewhat important.

As for a PP, me making copies of the test does not demonstrate it's importance - I have a vacation to pack for, I have a house to clean, I have errands to run, and I'm stalling! ;)
 
Yes, I had 2 other students in this class. I'm lucky - my kids are pretty on the ball, I believe kids need to be responsible for their schoolwork, so no, I don't monitor when they have quizzes and tests, and I don't go over their homework. I recall this particular study guide, because sometimes my older kids would ask me to quiz them. I have never volunteered in this class - our school doesn't have volunteers. The class moms bring in stuff for parties, and collect money for class gifts. She did read from the book - there was a question on the test that even I couldn't find in the chapter.

The study guide IS the test. I will have to get over seeing a B on a fourth grade report card. The only grades that really count in elementary school are in the 6th grade, because if you don't get an A, you don't get into vector in middle school, and then you don't get into honors in high school. I know that grades aren't the most important thing in the world, but when you have 5 kids you need to get through college, they're somewhat important.

As for a PP, me making copies of the test does not demonstrate it's importance - I have a vacation to pack for, I have a house to clean, I have errands to run, and I'm stalling! ;)

They'll be plenty of A's on there too :goodvibes
 
Are we even certain that the study guide was handed out? I know the OP said that here other kids had this teacher.

Could the study guide have been abolished in the class? Maybe they did a review game instead.. In some cases, study guides are only given out for students with IEPs. Teachers can change methods-- I know I do. If I gave out the same written study guide, that doesn't really help some students. Some of my students learn when paired in a group, doing an activity. Perhaps the teacher took a differentiation course over the summer!

I don't think the teacher failed. One B will not hurt ever. And dare I say even 6th grade is not that important either. I;ve had kids that bomb middle school and finally get it-- and are doing honors level work in high school.

Don't fret. If this is the worst worry you have, consider yourself blessed. So you won't have the perfect A report card.. it really isn't the end of the world.
 
Yes, I had 2 other students in this class. I'm lucky - my kids are pretty on the ball, I believe kids need to be responsible for their schoolwork, so no, I don't monitor when they have quizzes and tests, and I don't go over their homework. I recall this particular study guide, because sometimes my older kids would ask me to quiz them. I have never volunteered in this class - our school doesn't have volunteers. The class moms bring in stuff for parties, and collect money for class gifts. She did read from the book - there was a question on the test that even I couldn't find in the chapter.

The study guide IS the test. I will have to get over seeing a B on a fourth grade report card. The only grades that really count in elementary school are in the 6th grade, because if you don't get an A, you don't get into vector in middle school, and then you don't get into honors in high school. I know that grades aren't the most important thing in the world, but when you have 5 kids you need to get through college, they're somewhat important.

As for a PP, me making copies of the test does not demonstrate it's importance - I have a vacation to pack for, I have a house to clean, I have errands to run, and I'm stalling! ;)

If your high school REALLY won't let kids into their honors program because of a B in 6th grade, I would be spending my time worrying about THAT vs this test.
 
If your high school REALLY won't let kids into their honors program because of a B in 6th grade, I would be spending my time worrying about THAT vs this test.

I definetely agree.
 
AS far as I am concerned, she didn't fail, the teacher failed. If the work was requested and not given then it the teacher did fail. Now, it won't kill her, but still, it stinks. I have had this happen. Why is it that when a kid forgets something that they are irresponsible. Yet when a teacher forgets something, well then it was ok, (not saying you said this) You can't tie donw a teacher and force them to give you something, the work was requested, what is kid supposed to do, scream and yell until she gets it.

I had a teacher give my child a zero for something, funny, he actually got the work returned with a 100% on it. Also same thing happened to DD. Teachers aren't perfect and I understand this, but my kid won't demand work, they as for it, and if it isn't given then yes it is the teachers fault.

PS. My kids are in middle school and it is even harder because you change classes, giving even less time for you to talk with the teacher regarding missed work. Yep it is the kiddos' responsibility, but it is hard. This is why I tell my kids, unless you are dying, you are going to school. It is too much of a hassle to tie the teachers down and get the missed work The teachers have too much to do. There is no good answer, the whole thing stinks.

Our district starts changing classes in 4th grade. So to me this makes sense.
 
If your high school REALLY won't let kids into their honors program because of a B in 6th grade, I would be spending my time worrying about THAT vs this test.

I made the mistake of letting ds12 wing in in 6th grade (meaning me not being aware of tests and projects, or checking take-home tests). He ended up getting some bad grades, and when I met with the teacher in March, she said he just wasn't focusing (I had personally diagnosed him ADHD in 2nd grade, but his previous teachers said his grades were great, don't do anything about it - he's now medicated).

He is now in regular science, because his final grade in 6th grade was a B+ (a 90 here - he always scored advanced proficient in science), and he now has a 100+ average. He was also put in regular english because his final grade was an A-. I did go to his middle school over the summer, to see if I could get him into vector math, even though his final grade was an A-, and since he scored very high proficient on the standardized test, he got in. It's crazy!

Oh, and to answer a PP, I spoke with dd's bff's mom, who is in her class, and yes, there was a study guide.
 
I made the mistake of letting ds12 wing in in 6th grade (meaning me not being aware of tests and projects, or checking take-home tests). He ended up getting some bad grades, and when I met with the teacher in March, she said he just wasn't focusing (I had personally diagnosed him ADHD in 2nd grade, but his previous teachers said his grades were great, don't do anything about it - he's now medicated).

He is now in regular science, because his final grade in 6th grade was a B+ (a 90 here - he always scored advanced proficient in science), and he now has a 100+ average. He was also put in regular english because his final grade was an A-. I did go to his middle school over the summer, to see if I could get him into vector math, even though his final grade was an A-, and since he scored very high proficient on the standardized test, he got in. It's crazy!

Oh, and to answer a PP, I spoke with dd's bff's mom, who is in her class, and yes, there was a study guide.

But did you ask about getting him into Vector English and Science? I am assuming Vector is honors/advanced classes, right? Most schools will work with kids on things like this and I would HOPE that your high school understands that a lot of middle school students do like your son and slide through middle school but do well in high school.
 
But did you ask about getting him into Vector English and Science? I am assuming Vector is honors/advanced classes, right? Most schools will work with kids on things like this and I would HOPE that your high school understands that a lot of middle school students do like your son and slide through middle school but do well in high school.

I did not, and I'm beating myself up about it with science, since the only reason he got a B+ was for not following direction, and leaving out part of a project, which I didn't check (I have a BA in English, and he's not the best writer...). I'm confident he'll get an A in science this year, and put into vector next year, but having a really easy year isn't going to prepare him.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom