My absolute fav is the Yacht Club (stayed there twice, liked the non-concierge room better) cuz the location rocks, you can walk everywhere, and their pool is awesome. Second would probably be the GF, but it's kind of too Laura Ashley for my tastes. Stayed there with my family over new years '97/'98.
Third is the WL, the whole place is awesome except its kind of too 'in the woods', and the rooms are tiny...
JC