If its a reservation for a value or a moderate, the deal is barely ok- depending on the number of people in the room, it can work out to be better then 'free dining' or worse then 'free dining'. However, free dining has never been offered during these months before, so if you go in Jan-June, then, yup, its a good deal for you.
If you are staying at a deluxe like BC, it can save you up to $1500 off rack rate. I know, who pays rack rates on these boards, huh? Many of us are savvy disers, and know about discount codes and ap discount codes. Many of us have annual passes and dont need tickets anyways, so cant factor in any of the ticket savings either, so this 'sale' really would not net savvy dis users a $1500 savings, it may net them a $500 savings instead (just guessing and ball parking figures for arguements sake). This promotion also wont be tempting for DVCers, because already we stay at our deluxe resorts for savings of 43% off already, and have prepaid for the priviledge.
What I am interested in is how this affects the seldom disney goer who does not have DVC or annual passes, who does not own at dvc, and who would like to try out deluxe resorts on site. They wont have an annual pass. They want to try out a 2 bedroom villa at BCV, and with this promotion, they can get 40% off rack rate. I am not sure, but has the CRO ever offered 40% off DVC villas with any kind of general discount or annual pass discount? I dont think so, but I could be wrong. What is the best DVC Villa discount you have ever seen?
The route I was going to take them would be to 'rent points' to get that 40% discount on the DVC villas. As the professor pointed out - this promotion basically equals or betters renting points at the going rate, with the added bonus of
1)mousekeeping
2)great cancellation policy
3)low deposit requirement
4)NO RISK
The ticket savings are close to negligble, because of the way Disney front loads the ticket prices, so they dont really factor in at all.
Now, I also want to point out that many posters on these boards can figure out to a nickle what the best deal is, they know every discount out there. That is why many of us are so/so or even suprised about the hype on the new deal.
But think for a minute of the GENERAL POPULATION of Disney resort guests. Probably less then 80% know what a discount code is, renting dvc points are or what mousesavers/disboards are. They walk into a
travel agency and say "we want to go to Disney and stay at (fill in the blank). The agent says --- guess what! I can save you 40% -- thats the hype. Now just imagine the person who pays rack rate for deluxe (oh yes, there are many of them out there) guess how they would react when they can save $1500 bucks at a deluxe resort? They will be happy.
I think that this is a very good deal if you dont own dvc, and you want to stay at a deluxe resort. I think its a very good deal if you want to stay in a one or two bedroom villa at DVC. So, although it wont be a HUGE deal to many disers and DVCers, to the general population, and infreqent disney goers, it can be a great deal.